💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 02

The aligned-interests con

The asset managers, for their part, are putting out comms left, right and centre to try to reassure the market. Or not, as it happens.

Despite €15.5bn pulled out of euro funds in H1 2023, insurers are keeping fairly quiet. About the only thing we’ve seen is Corum showing off by launching a euro fund promising a return > 4%, to beat the Livret A, according to its boss. Joined by Nexity, the French property developer (via Suravenir), and Anaxago (Generali), with property-focused policies. With a nice little 3% fee on unit-linked funds (and more for SCPIs) at Nexity. Got to make up for all those unsold new-builds somehow!

Over at the SCPIs, as it happens, the mood is #NotAllSCPIs.

  • Those whose prices aren’t falling explain that theirs is bigger (their performance, that is)
  • Those whose prices are falling explain that it’s not their fault, it’s the market

Except the market has been falling for a while. As soon as inflation went up, everyone knew rates would rise. And therefore that prices would fall.

Which raises the question of why they kept buying when it was obvious prices were going to crash. And you can ask the same question about the whole 2020-2022 period, when SCPIs raised record amounts that had to be spent quickly, or else yields would have to come down.

And this is where one of finance’s finest PR cons comes in: the famous “aligned interests”. A masterclass in bullshit.

NOBODY who collects savings has interests aligned with investors.

Take crowdfunding: the platform makes money on the projects it offers. So it has no reason to be very picky about the quality of those projects, or it risks not having enough of them. Worse: why take lots of security when it brings the platform nothing but costs? For its first two bond projects, the only security Bricks took was a “promesse hypothécaire” (a mere promise to grant a mortgage) from the brother of Bricks’s boss.

By contrast, the platforms that bought properties to run them and hand back part of the rent (the former royalties model, which the AMF, France’s financial markets regulator, banned) already had far more interests in common.

Worse still. A PSFP platform (a licensed French crowdfunding provider) has displayed, at least twice, a mortgage it had never taken. The AMF will be thrilled.

But this misalignment exists for every investment. And when you think about it, it makes sense: when you call a plumber, his interests aren’t the same as yours. Nor are your grocer’s. And that’s fine!

In an SCPI, the manager takes 8-12% upfront, for itself and to pay for distribution. Why cap how much it raises? Especially as it then takes another 10 to 15% a year out of the rent. So the money has to be invested.

On the flip side: do the managers pay anything at all when there are losses? Do the investors have any recourse whatsoever? None at all. Although a big-name lawyer is currently trying to reach investors who have lost money, to bring a class action against these managers (if you’re reading this, get in touch).

Even better. Several well-informed insiders, including a property fund manager, told me that one of the reasons for the very big markdowns… was to stop savers from bailing out. At -5%, you can tell yourself it’s a small loss, you’ve collected rent, and you end up roughly breaking even. At -15 or -17%, you need some balls (or an urgent need for cash) to cash out…

Similar reasoning, to a different degree, has been followed by several SCIs (another kind of French property fund), notably Capimmo. Short of cash, the fund draws up a fire-sale plan in case a lot of money had to be paid out. The fund’s net asset value is set as if that plan were to happen. Those who leave are therefore “taxed” for that potential loss (which does not happen as long as there is cash), while those who stay (or come in) will get a higher value if the fund doesn’t need cash.

And we could go on like this, testing every investment, including equity, where performance is collapsing, FCPIs (French tax-break innovation funds: nobody has ever seen a profitable one) and more, and it doesn’t get any better.

The reality is that while managers earn more if their financial products work, they don’t lose anything if they don’t.

And it gets even better one floor down: the advisers.