💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 01

The Livret A scandal

In February 2020, the rate on the Livret A (France’s tax-free, state-regulated savings account) drops from 0.75% to 0.5%. Every seller of financial products jumps on it with a killer argument:

The Livret pays 0.5%, inflation is at 2%, so you’re losing 1.5% a year. Thanks to MYPRODUCT.com, you’ll finally make some money.

And there’s no shortage of examples. Let’s take a fun one.

Here’s how Mon Petit Placement, a French online investment platform, was bashing the Livret A in 2020:

And here’s how its balanced portfolio (called Énergétique) has performed since.

3 of its 4 portfolios have done far worse than the Livret A since they were launched

  • Volontaire (Determined): 0% return over 5 years
  • Énergétique (Energetic): -0.4% since that post, 2.6% a year over 8 years
  • Ambitieux (Ambitious): -0.3% since that post, 8.5% a year over 9 years
  • Intrépide (Fearless): +29.9% since that post, 17% a year over 8 years

I’ve lost count of the SCPIs that ran the same line (I even wrote several pieces of marketing copy along those lines myself for an employer, and I was always against it). Yet since 2020, SCPIs have yielded 4.2-4.4%. In other words, with a 30% marginal income tax rate, you are in fact barely keeping up with inflation after tax. And well below it today.

Now that the Livret A pays 3%, hardly anyone dares to bash it, even with inflation at 6%. Not in public, anyway.

The Livret A rate has always been linked to inflation. The formula is even written into law. Until 2018, it could not be lower than inflation, excluding tobacco. The reality is that the State always sets the rate, end of story. The law? They couldn’t care less. It’s legal, but it was supposed to be reserved for exceptional circumstances.

This summer, the legal formula gave a rate of 4.10%. Several senior officials at the Banque de France (the French central bank) and at Bercy (the French finance ministry) told me that many had lobbied for a rise from 3 to 4%.

But neither our national treasure Bruno Le Maire, the finance minister, nor the governor of the Banque de France agreed. And why on earth not, when it would be wildly popular? Because the mega banking and finance lobbies went to war.

With a 4% rate, the people who sell savings products were terrified of heavy outflows, at a time when life insurance policies (assurance-vie, France’s favourite savings wrapper) were already seeing withdrawals. To be fair, insurers keep churning out euro funds (the capital-guaranteed part of those policies) paying 2%, while 10-year US Treasuries yield 4.3% and 2-year ones almost 5%.

The governor of the Banque de France (the one who didn’t see inflation coming, then said it would fade by mid-2022, then by the end of 2022, then in 2023, then “oh for crying out loud, give it a rest”) justified himself:

Freezing the rate at 3% was, he said, a promise made in the saver’s favour

The nerve.