💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 11

Nothing to see here

I had been working on the story for 2 months when, in December 2023, testimonies start pouring in.

For some, it’s a return to hell, because they had already struggled to get out of their contract. That’s the case for Elise:

Elise says she took out insurance at Fnac in 2019 when she bought her phone. She was debited 3 times €29.99 despite cancelling 1 year later. She had been appalled by the testimonies online, but after a few months they had refunded her. Then, when she saw 4 SFAM debits in December 2023, she says she nearly fell off her chair.

Amélie tells the same story.

She thought the problem had been “sorted” since 2020. Then came a second wave of debits, followed by a third [at the end of 2023].

The testimonies I received are anything but anecdotal. On the Facebook group set up by people who lost out to SFAM, there are hundreds of them. In fact, a few days later, the consumer magazine Que Choisir publishes an article telling the same story, almost word for word.

While it’s hard to know whether testimonies reflect a widespread practice, it’s still striking to see the number of posts in the Facebook group explode between December 2023 and January 2024. Even before the media picked the story up more widely.

So the question has to be asked.

Did Indexia deliberately steal its customers’ money for several months to refill its own coffers?

An accountant who audited the group in 2018 says the undue debits were brought to light by his firm. And we’re talking a lot of money.

  • €300K for SFAM
  • €800K for Foriou

Amounts the firm he worked for considered negligible compared with revenue. The fact remains that in 2018, when:

  • The practice had been going on for at least 5 years;
  • The group had not yet reached its peak;
  • The figures only concern 2 companies (so neither Hubside nor Serena);

The group had stolen at least €1.1M from its customers. This order of magnitude was confirmed to me by two other internal sources, who arrived later.

It’s impossible to put an exact figure on the amount stolen from customers, but it may well exceed ten million euros.

A tidy sum, since Indexia keeps 100% of it. When the company’s deputy CEO talks about a billion in business volume to dazzle investors, he’s mixing up revenue and insurance premiums collected.

Yet an insurance premium… goes to the insurer. The broker keeps 1 to 3% as commission. But with abusive debits… it’s 100% profit.

The overall damage, though, remains unknown, because the number of complaints is probably far lower than the number of victims.

Like Amélie, many (a good share of them women) tell me they give up because they don’t know how to go about it, or because it costs too much.

That’s the case for Céline, who has racked up unpaid claims, abusive debits and contracts added without her knowledge.

She says she hasn’t taken the matter to court, because she can’t afford a lawyer for €500-odd.

How many other claims will never be filed?