💥 Zero Bullshit
Epilogue

The coup de grâce

So it was the URSSAF that dealt the first fatal blow.

But the scam, because I think we can use that word, went on to the very end, as Marion’s story shows.

From the very next day, a large share of the group’s websites and phone lines were cut off.

Among SFAM’s 300 employees, the blow has landed, even if it was foreseeable, according to a union representative at head office.

He says it wasn’t really a surprise for staff, even if management said otherwise.

Internally, nobody knows how these redundancies will be handled, and no offer has been made. As I finish writing this (Thursday 25 April 2024), Sadri Fegaier is at head office in Romans-sur-Isère, in a meeting with staff representatives.

In the offices, opinions are divided. Some are dejected, others relieved. Because many had been living badly with the situation for months. Several even helped customers see their claims through.

As for what comes next… I can’t see any way out.

SFAM has been liquidated, and the group’s other entities live on. But for how much longer?

Because as we’ve seen, the companies mostly live off each other. That’s the case, for example, of the call centres in Roanne. They have only one client: SFAM. How can anyone imagine those 160 employees carrying on working? In the space of 1 year, 500 employees have already left the group under a PSE23.

On that subject, I’ve received more than a dozen testimonies (8 of them after my LinkedIn post (in French)) about unpaid wages, refusals to sign off end-of-contract agreements or to hand over the mandatory paperwork.

All the more so since, following the DGCCRF’s 2022 findings, the Paris prosecutor’s office has summoned Indexia and 7 subsidiaries to appear in court in May and June 2024. The consumer association UFC-Que Choisir and at least 400 victims have already joined the case as civil parties, according to the association. More than 550, according to a recent judicial source. CFDT Banque et Assurance, the banking and insurance branch of the CFDT trade union, will also be a civil party.
The merits of the case should be heard in the autumn of 2024.
The liquidation won’t change any of that.

For the customers wrongly debited by SFAM, things look more complicated.
If the company was liquidated over its URSSAF debt, it’s because there isn’t a penny left in the coffers. With the state ranking first among creditors, there will be nothing left for the customers it owes money to.

But the story may not be over…

Because Sadri Fegaier has a fortune of €2bn according to the business magazine Challenges in 2022. Despite an estimated loss of €600M (he is now only the 87th richest person in France), he remains one of the youngest billionaires.

Granted, that’s his personal wealth, and it is no doubt closely tied to the value of his companies. But Sadri Fegaier is a legal officer of all his companies, and therefore liable for possible management failings, in particular for letting the debts pile up once the company could no longer pay them.

The ruling isn’t public yet, but it’s really very surprising that the liquidation was ordered on the spot, at the hearing. It means there isn’t the slightest hope. And therefore that the company had probably been unable to pay its debts since well before today.

Yet at the hearing, Fegaier tried everything. Up to offering to spread the debt over 12 months. While being unable to explain how he would find €1M a month from a business with hopelessly empty coffers. Same answer when he offered to stand personal guarantor.

If a link were made between SFAM’s financial situation and the sudden return of debits years after cancellation, that could change everything and make Fegaier personally liable.

More broadly, if it were shown that this whole galaxy of companies spent years knowingly getting round the law to wrongly take money from customers, that could also make Fegaier liable.

So in reality, the beginning of the end is probably only just beginning.

My name is Benjamin Charles, and I advise companies in finance, real estate and web3 on branding, positioning and content creation.

👉 To contact me, or reply to this post: benj@mincharl.es

👉 Send me a brief for a business project

👉 Follow me on LinkedIn

👉 Book a video call to present a project or service (€250 per call)