💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 10

Three strikes

Throughout 2023, the group tries to find a way out. The media situation is untenable, and it will end up costing dearly. A former executive of the group explains it to me.

He says Sadri [Fegaier] had no strategy to revive the group. He asked the communications team to save… himself. Loads of press releases went out, not about the group, but about him.

I found no trace of the press releases sent to the media. On the other hand, you can still find several adverts bought in L’Express1415, Le Figaro16 or the retail trade magazine LSA17. The last one praises services designed to boost consumers’ purchasing power, the work of the group’s founder and CEO, the businessman Sadri Fegaier.

How ironic.

According to several other internal sources, nobody imagined Indexia was in trouble. A manager at the time explains it to me.

The official line going round, he says, was that it was a settling of scores between Fnac and Indexia. Nobody was fooled, mind you. But everyone assumed revenue was stable.

Behind the scenes, things are more complicated.

At the end of 2022, following the Fnac Darty affair, Axeria terminates its contract. And at the start of 2023, Covéa (the group MMA now belongs to) tells SFAM it will take on no more contracts. According to L’Argus de l’assurance, the insurance trade weekly, Fegaier reportedly secured a reprieve until the end of 202318. Information a source inside MMA calls completely false. Or quite simply made false 1 month later.

Under pressure from members of parliament calling for an investigation, deputy CEO Jean-Pierre Galera announces in March 2023 that insurance now accounts for only 20% of a business volume of €1bn.19

More surprising still, on 21 April 2023, Indexia sends a statement to France Bleu Drôme Ardèche, the local public radio station, saying it is suspending its insurance business, which accounted for only 10% of its business volume20. Halved in 1 month, then.

The real reason arrives 6 days later, when the ACPR, France’s banking and insurance supervisor, comes down hard.

The ACPR stated that the practices it had found in the sales process put in place by SFAM were likely to harm customers’ interests and had already given rise to a significant number of complaints.

The regulator orders a temporary but immediate ban on distributing any insurance contract. A measure still in force today.

The former Indexia executive describes the mood to me.

He says that right up to the last moment, management was convinced they would just get a fine or a warning. The suspension came as a huge shock.

Another employee tells me what happened next.

To keep the numbers up, staff were asked to steer as many insurance contracts or prospects as possible towards the other subscriptions [my note: unregulated ones], this employee says.

But perhaps another solution had been dreamt up.

On 13 December 2023, L’Argus de l’assurance reveals that Sadri Fegaier tried to buy Parachut21, a subsidiary of the broker Advise specialising in affinity insurance.

According to a source close to the ACPR, the regulator reportedly took a very dim view of this rather odd attempt to get round its ban.

The deal is said to have fallen through because Advise said no. But someone familiar with the group’s internal finances tells me that, whatever happened, financing would have been very difficult.

This source says interest rates had gone up, the figures had gone down, the sanctions were piling up and the debt wasn’t shrinking. The long-standing partners no longer wanted to put money in.

Still, the group is struggling to stay afloat. Sadri Fegaier even gives an interview to local papers in March 2023, something he had always refused to do.

In reality, the rot had set in, and the worm was starting to get peckish.

Under pressure from members of parliament, notably the Communist MP for Seine-Saint-Denis, near Paris, Stéphane Peu22, the French Economy Ministry asks Bpifrance, France’s public investment bank, to pull out of Indexia. This is done after the summer: Mubadala buys FEF’s 9% through 41st investment company, a fund it owns that was already a shareholder in the group.

But last January, the whole supervisory board resigns, and with it the group’s 3 last shareholders:

  • Ardian (17%)
  • Mubadala (9%)
  • Andera (0.3%)

Fegaier leaks the information that none of them has sold their shares, proof of their confidence. The reality is crueller: nobody wants to buy them.

In the meantime, Indexia has been forced to sell its stake in Fnac Darty to IPC, which had financed it. Taking a loss of €265M.