Fnac Darty’s stance quickly catches on. Every other partner and distributor cuts ties. Some even win court rulings.
But the authorities are prowling too.
The DGCCRF is back on the attack in April 2022, over misleading commercial practices by Indexia10, and it doesn’t mince its words. The watchdog refers to a large number of complaints and to unlawful practices that falsely led consumers to believe they would be refunded, or that their cancellation had gone through (when it hadn’t), in order to keep a large number of contracts active.
According to the DGCCRF, its investigation found practices that consisted of falsely leading consumers who wanted to stop the direct debits, cancel their subscriptions and get back the sums taken after their contract ended to believe that their requests had been taken into account, or even acted upon.
In the meantime, the CNIL, France’s data protection authority, has also been through. In 2021 it carries out an inspection of Foriou1112. According to an internal source, this was both because it had heard about SFAM’s practices, and because of complaints about aggressive cold-calling.
The CNIL notably accuses Foriou of buying databases of phone numbers and calling them relentlessly.
But also of running prize draws to collect data, without ever saying clearly that the purpose was to sell to the participants.
On 31 January 2024, the CNIL fines Foriou €310,000, with the sanction published under the company’s name for 2 years.
And at that point, the CNIL clearly doesn’t know that the company is still:
In April 2024, it’s Hubside’s turn to be fined €525,000 by the CNIL for… exactly the same reasons13. An amount said to represent 2% of the company’s revenue (that is, €26M).
But a third authority has the group in its sights.