At the end of 2017, the group buys Actualys, a website design and digital marketing agency, in order to launch Hubside the following year and sell websites on subscription.
It doesn’t really take off. But during 2020, Indexia decides to return to physical retail, using its Hubside brand.
The idea? Selling high-tech, phones in particular… and of course the insurance and subscriptions that go with them. New, refurbished and rental products are brought together in a kind of mini Apple Store, almost exclusively franchised.
To kick things off, Indexia buys the Belgian Switch shops, quickly rebranded. 30 outlets are open at launch, a few dozen more follow.
But Sadri Fegaier was thinking bigger.
In 2018, he invests more than €335M for 11.35% of Fnac Darty, his biggest distributor, which he dreams of controlling. To structure the deal:
Buying Knight Vinke’s stake makes Indexia the second-largest shareholder in Fnac Darty.
A few months later, the Caisse des Dépôts, the French state’s public investment arm, and Mubadala6 buy in through FEF7, their joint fund. The two rounds value Indexia at €1.7bn.
A unicorn that will never make it onto any ranking of tech stars.
Except the story is about to go wrong.
Because the many complaints end up reaching the ears of the authorities, which open lengthy investigations. The DGCCRF, France’s consumer protection and anti-fraud watchdog, strikes first.
After a long investigation, the DGCCRF, the Paris prosecutor’s office and SFAM agree a €10M settlement fine8. A penalty the authority described as proportionate to the seriousness of the practices, which it said had been found to be unfair commercial practices. All the consumers affected are invited to come forward by 31 August to be compensated.
The fine shakes Fegaier, whose group is heavily in debt.
But also Fnac Darty.
Its new reference shareholder, the German electronics retail group Ceconomy, has little taste for media storms.
In 2019, Fnac Darty ends the partnership, which is wrapped up in a settlement in April 2022.
Except the last one was never paid.
Fnac Darty sues Hubside and SFAM, which are ordered to pay the balance plus damages. That won’t stop Fnac Darty from filing a complaint a few days ago, under pressure from its many customer complaints. In L’Informé9, a French news site, Fnac Darty’s CEO, Enrique Martinez, nevertheless explains:
According to him, the customers who had been wrongly signed up to this kind of contract were helped by the group.