In reality, in May 2017, Patrick Lenoël lands at Apicap as deputy CEO, with the confident stride of a man who has seen nearly thirty years of property cycles. The veteran of Paris property arrives as if he owned the place. Alain Esnault, Apicap’s chief executive, welcomes him like the messiah who will turn this old private-equity shop into a modern property machine. As he tells the press13.
Launching this property business, he says, is the result of recurring demand from clients.
In reality, it is mostly the result of a business model running out of steam.
Esnault himself, despite his grand-sounding qualifications (the Edhec business school, the Centrale engineering school, the SFAF financial analysts’ diploma), is not exactly a finance ace. His claim to fame? Having been CFO of the steakhouse chain Buffalo Grill and of a few large SMEs. He joined OTC Agregator in 2013, became chief executive of Apicap in 2016, then took over as chairman in October 2018, succeeding Jérôme Lescure. Someone very close to the matter at the time of the rebranding as Apicap describes a team of bumbling amateurs with no real track record in private equity or property, desperately looking for experienced people. Hence the providential arrival of old man Lenoël.
Except that Lenoël arrives in a house already undermined by past mistakes: Apicap is still dragging around a dozen of those zombie tax funds in liquidation, toxic relics of the OTC era.
Because Apicap, born in September 2015 in unusual circumstances through an LBO, is already dragging its 34 tax-break funds for SMEs like a ball and chain. The press release at the time hailed a coming-together of two investors sharing a strong entrepreneurial culture. The reality is less glorious. The inventory of past funds is dizzying: the FCPIs (funds investing in innovative SMEs, which earn French savers an income-tax reduction) OTC Entreprises 1 to 4; the regional FIPs, their local-SME cousins (OTC Régions Nord, Sud, Centre Est, Centre Ouest, all in duplicate); the PME 974 series (six generations for Réunion, the French island in the Indian Ocean); the Apicap Corse Croissance funds for Corsica (five vintages that will be sold to Vatel to pay off the LBO); the Ardens professional private-equity funds (II, III, and IV split from A to K like an alphabet primer of complexity); plus dedicated funds with more evocative names such as Sushi Shop, Trust Esport, Spécial Luxe. A catalogue of tax vehicles stacked up with no apparent logic or conviction.
To understand all this, you have to go back to the beginning.
Guillaume-Olivier Doré (already mentioned in the newsletter on Tudigo (in French)), a serial entrepreneur, had founded Agregator Capital in 2002. The first entrepreneurs’ investment fund created in France, backed by a club of 350 entrepreneurs and family groups. Doré also co-founded Theraclion the same year, then Viadeo in 2005, two companies that would go public.
In June 2012, Agregator Capital launches its IPO on Euronext Paris14, hoping to raise €35M to keep investing in unlisted companies. It has already invested €6M in firms such as NovaWatt and Ad4Screen. But the IPO flops. In the summer of 2012, the market slips away and investors are wary. Doré pivots with a surprising deal: buying the retail private-equity business of Tocqueville Finance, OTC Asset Management, and its €360M of assets. Agregator Capital, which managed only €50M, swallows something 9x its size. The new entity, OTC Agregator, now manages €400M through 34 investment vehicles and finances more than 400 companies, including Boursorama and Nocibé. The stated goal: raise €50M a year through FIP and FCPI funds. The machine runs well, but in 2015, Doré wants to move on.
The story shifts when 123IM is put up for sale. OTC Agregator’s historical shareholders dream of a merger, but Jérôme Lescure, a minority shareholder, flatly refuses. No question of diluting his family funds, partly managed by OTC Agregator, with the rest. At the same time, Doré sells his shares to Lescure, who shares them with the existing team, in July 2015. The timing is perfect for Lescure, who imposes his vision: it will be an LBO. And he renames the whole thing Apicap.
To do club deals, he keeps Alain Esnault, the group’s former finance director, who goes from operations to licensed fund manager. The deal is built around a structure in which OTC managed, among other things, the FIPs and FCPIs of the Tocqueville Finance range. The whole thing then weighs €500M of AUM (€350M OTC, €100M Agregator, the rest Ardens), €15M of revenue and €4M of EBIT, in a fine cash machine whose shares are carved up as follows:
💡 Lescure is not just anybody: from the founding family of SEB, the French small-appliance group, he is a direct descendant of Antoine Lescure, the itinerant tinsmith from Dijon who opened his tinware workshop in 1857 and laid the foundations of a household-appliance empire. A family whose fortune is estimated at just under €2bn in 2025, after a hefty 25% markdown in a year.
But Jérôme is not the type to rest on the family laurels.
A former partner at AT Kearney, where he took part in the buyout of the firm in the early 1990s, then involved in developing Eurodisney before moving to Accenture, he threw himself into entrepreneurship at full speed. Not in fashionable start-ups, no: this grandson of the founder of SEB prefers awkward businesses in provincial France. He has backed care homes, invested in Brassac Industries, an 80-strong timber processor in the Tarn with €15M of revenue, and even saved 15 jobs at a sawmill under court-protected restructuring near Carcassonne.
It is this Lescure who imposes his vision in 2015 when it comes to structuring Apicap. No question of mixing his family interests with just anything. The set-up gives the new entity a veneer of provincial, bourgeois respectability, but the ownership structure reveals scaffolding worthy of a Luxembourg tax arrangement.
In 2020, Apicap is controlled by Apicap Holding, itself controlled by Douz’Capital, itself owned by Financière A, where the stakes of Arielle Esnault (13% of the capital, 71% of the votes), Henri Gagnaire (68%, 22%) and Mr and Mrs Lescure (24%) are intertwined. A layer cake that lets everyone keep their slice while diluting responsibility. On 1 January 2021, this contraption employs only 18 people to manage 35,000 clients. That ratio says it all about the attention paid to savers.
But as in any hastily arranged marriage, the union is far from perfect. The forty or so tax funds inherited from OTC (FCPIs, FIPs) no longer fit the new positioning.