💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 05

No limit

The reasons for opposing rent control are many, but broadly they come mainly from free-market liberals and from landlords.

For the liberals, it’s philosophical, even dogmatic: everyone should be free. In reality, freedom is a very relative notion. European economic liberals mostly end up in parties that are conservative on social issues (abortion, religion, LGBT rights, etc.). Conversely, parties leaning left are liberal on social issues, but want to restrict freedoms as soon as markets are involved.

It might seem like a digression, but it’s actually very close to the subject, because it helps you understand the methods used, depending on the ideology of the people putting them in place.

For landlords, the reasons are easier to understand: if rents are controlled, and therefore capped, that potentially means less money coming in.

The arguments are pretty much always the same, and rarely made in good faith:

  • Landlords will be more selective: obviously that was already the case, nobody has ever picked the shakiest application or the least reliable person;
  • There’ll be less money for upkeep: as long as decency standards (including energy standards) are enforced, landlords will have obligations. And past decades haven’t exactly shown massive investment, particularly in energy renovation;
  • Landlords will stop letting: as we saw above, I don’t really see why, or what they’d gain;
  • Prices will fall: probably, and that’s not a bad thing, including for landlords, since they’ll be able to buy for less.