💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 06

Hubble, bubble

At the end of October, the big-data proptech PriceHubble9 released a study on the French market.10 The idea was to see whether:

  • Rents had fallen;
  • The number of listings had fallen.

On the first point, the annual barometers of the Fondation Abbé Pierre, a French housing charity, tend to show that while quite a few landlords are still breaking the law, most are slowly falling into line.11 Cuts that have a fairly small impact on rents (7.3% in 4 years), according to PriceHubble, which nonetheless notes a significant drop in the number of properties put up for rent.

So there you have it: proof that rent control has made a right mess of things.

Change in quarterly rental listings and in median rent including service charges, indexed to 100, nationwide

Whoa, whoa, whoa, hold your horses. If you’ve read my recent post on Simpson’s paradox, you know you can’t jump to conclusions that easily. Because there are thousands of reasons why it could have fallen.

  • A listings site shutting down, or changing its terms;
  • PriceHubble changing its methodology;
  • Landlords favouring family members for lack of good enough offers;
  • More properties on short lets;
  • etc.

And it’s always a mix of several causes anyway. Across France, the drop is around 39%.

But PriceHubble also looked at the cities where rents were controlled:

  • Paris: +10% for rents, -61% in volume
  • Lille: +11%, -35%
  • Lyon/Villeurbanne: +9%, -37%
  • Bordeaux: +5%, -50%
  • Montpellier: +7%, -37%

Here again there’s a big confounding factor, since these are listings posted online. You can imagine that those who want to get around the rent cap avoid advertising their offence online.

As for the cities that could join the scheme soon:

  • Marseille: +15%, -39%
  • Rennes: +17%, -44%
  • Grenoble: +9%, -26%

And for the freestyle cities:

  • Toulouse: +11%, -39%
  • Tours: +10%, -17%
  • Nantes: +11%, -25%
  • Strasbourg: +19%, -37%
  • Nice: +15%, -53%
  • Brest: +20%, -32%
  • Angers: +19%, -28%

And now the conclusion is less straightforward…

  • Increases are more moderate in cities with rent control;
  • Some cities without rent control have seen insane increases;
  • The drop in supply is no sharper in cities with rent control than in those without.

The moral of the story: while you can clearly see that rent control helps contain increases, the empirical evidence doesn’t show any effect on supply, which a study by the Apur, the Paris urban planning agency, had already suggested.12