For rent control, or any measure at all, to be effective, it has to be:
Take the ban on letting out energy sieves, the worst-insulated homes. For the 20 years since the Kyoto Protocol introduced these measures, nobody gave a damn. It took the bans voted in 2021 for landlords to wake up. And for the past 4 years, rather than doing the work, everyone has been complaining about a timetable that nobody is even trying to meet. Since everyone knows the politicians will end up caving under the pressure.
For this measure to be effective, you have to do the opposite and keep the pressure on the housing stock and on landlords. If the owner of a studio rated G, the bottom energy grade, can let it neither on a long-term lease nor as a short let, well, either they do the work or they sell. And the turnover of the stock will put prices into competition, and the market will do its job.
But the market is like kids: if it sees the parents give in to every tantrum, it won’t bother following the rules.
Because honestly, you haven’t got 50 options:
At what point can anyone think someone is going to stick with option 2? At what point would you rather tie up a dead asset for 10 years than accept a lower yield, or reshuffle and change your allocation?