💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 02

Let’s dance

Rent control is a mechanism where a public body sets a price level, based on specific criteria, to make housing more affordable. Three big side effects have been predicted6:

  • It brings in new residents, since the existing ones don’t benefit from the arrangement, which causes population movements and pushes newcomers towards lower-quality properties;
  • Lower rents lead to lower prices (see below), which in turn lead to less spending on the property;
  • Lower prices attract more people, which artificially creates excess demand, or a mismatch between demand and the type of property available.

In reality, this theory… has never been proven empirically, at least not in full, and the same goes for most others of the kind. The reason is that rent controls have been applied in very different ways, with very different criteria, and therefore with different results.

Because you can set a price, but also exemptions and adjustments depending on the property, the tenants, the neighbourhood, the amenities, etc. Even if that means ending up with bureaucratic contraptions.

In Germany, the Mietpreisbremse, the “rent brake” introduced in 2015, only applies to very specific neighbourhoods. Rent control in New York only covers landlords with more than 6 units, while smaller ones are exempt, which is more an indirect way of taxing wealth than of controlling rents.

Or, at the other extreme, you get oversimplification, as in Paris, where prices are set according to location and “amenities” (never spelled out except in case law), but without ever taking into account the DPE, France’s energy performance rating, for example, even though it has a big impact on the tenant. You could perfectly well have imagined allowing the cap to be lifted gradually, or tightened, depending on the DPE.