💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 01

And there was light

Depending on the country, housing accounts for 20 to 60% of a middle-class household’s budget. Obviously that means everything and nothing, but it does show that it’s a big chunk of a budget. For owners, it covers taxes, a mortgage for twenty-odd years, and upkeep. For tenants, it’s mainly the rent, which never stops, plus service charges, but those are smaller. Still, the ideal maximum burden is estimated at 30%1, which, incidentally, fits the old French landlord’s rule that you have to earn 3 times the rent. Not only because of the risk of unpaid rent, but also because of consumption: a household with too many outgoings doesn’t spend, and that’s bad for the economy.

In France, tenants are over-represented in the working and lower-middle classes, while the number of tenants is tending to fall.

Number of tenants in the private rental sector2

Distribution of taxable income per consumption unit in 20173

That’s no coincidence. Even if plenty of people (who have a conflict of interest in saying so) will tell you that you’re better off investing in a buy-to-let than in your own home, your main home makes up 83% of household wealth on average4. That’s how many people manage to get by in retirement: not because they have extra income, but because their home is paid off, which is a sharp drop in monthly outgoings.

Since the end of the First World War, the price of housing has haunted many countries, at various times, but it has become a major issue since the 2010s, with jobs, and therefore people, ultra-concentrated in big cities that build very few homes, some of which leave the long-term rental market (short lets, holiday homes, second homes, offices, etc.).

In France, the famous Friggit curve, which tracks house prices against household income, has shown just how far property prices have exploded, to the point of becoming completely decoupled from incomes.

That isn’t the case for rents, though, which are rather on a downward trend.

And inevitably: rising prices + falling rents = falling yields. Which is therefore complete nonsense.

Because in reality, a landlord can’t do anything about the price of the property, so any adjustment to the yield will mostly come through the rent. Except that in practice, it’s hard to genuinely index rents to inflation.5