💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 03

Opaque transparency

Because the other big part of the report is devoted to life insurance (assurance-vie, France’s favourite savings product), looking in particular at the split between euro funds and UCs21. In other words, the difference between the guaranteed and the risky, the former making up the vast majority of allocations.

Here again, the idea is to promote UCs, deemed higher-yielding on the strength of a study by France Assureurs. Which is factually true. But here again, it is an average.

That said, the report does not just swallow the managers’ view whole, and devotes several pages to fees, citing in turn senators Husson and Montgolfier22 and France Conso Banque, which talks of opacity and of performance eaten away. Which leads the rapporteurs to call for the relevance of fees to be assessed regularly. Which means everything and nothing. Mostly nothing.

Because it would be dishonest to say that regulation has brought consumers nothing in recent years. But it is an understatement to say that every line of this kind of report ends up either at the bottom of a binder that nobody will ever open, or in some never-ending regulation that results in prospectus-type documents, where an investor is told over 100 pages what he will never read.

And on this subject, as on just about every other, the report never really tackles the question the right way. It even… ignores the regulation. On life insurance, for example, the report claims that the French cannot know how much they pay in fees, because of the sheer number of lines and layers (the broker’s, the manager’s, the intermediaries’ etc.). Which is simply false.

I had in fact flagged this very point about Green Got, whose communication is false and misleading, advertising 1.6% in fees and nothing more, and pricing it calls clear, when the fee details are not on its website, and in reality the 1.6% does not include the fees of the underlying funds. Which runs completely counter to the regulation23.

The problem here is not the law. It is that a player decides not to apply it. That no regulator steps in. And that politicians don’t understand any of it.