As my grandfather used to say: Primonial doesn't get out of bed for free. So how much was the manager paid for this enormous mess, its catastrophic management, its lack of vision, and the few billion euros lost by savers?
Because this whole story was sold, and it didn't sell itself.
First through a network of independent wealth advisers paid for distribution through the subscription fee, which is 10.617% excl. VAT of the subscription price, issue premium included, of which 9.867% is fundraising costs intended, among other things, for the distributors' intermediary work. Out of €100 subscribed, nearly 10 go into the sales chain before a single euro buys any bricks. Depending on the period, the contracts and the sources, these distributors reportedly received between 5 and 7.5%. For filling in a subscription form in a few dozen minutes, far more easily than finding a buy-to-let investment or restructuring someone's wealth.
Still, one question remains. Why?
The annual reports were public, free, and could be read in an hour. So let's be clear. An adviser who sold Primopierre after 2018:
But the bulk of the inflows came from elsewhere: from insurers, who held the units in their policies and brought in most of the money: Humanis, Spirica, Suravenir, BPCE Vie, Sogecap, to name a few at random. 5 that sat for several years on Primopierre's supervisory board… alongside Capimmo20. Yes, Primonial was supervising itself, all grown up.
But the conflict of interest runs wider. Suravenir, for example, holds Primopierre units in its Sérénipierre policy. And Suravenir's parent company, Crédit Mutuel Arkéa, bought into the Primonial group in 2014, at 45% through convertible bonds according to the joint press release, a joint takeover with the executives cleared by the French competition authority in 201415. Latour Capital and BlackFin would follow as early as 2015, through the same door54. The fundraiser whose parent owns the maker: at the same time, the same group collects on the policy, sits on the oversight body and takes its cut at the sponsor.
The chain of the paid
The member
Out of €100 subscribed, nearly 10 go into the sales chain before a single euro buys any bricks.
The adviser
Paid out of the fundraising costs: between 5 and 7.5% of the amount subscribed, depending on the period, the contracts and the sources.
The insurer
Holds the units in its life insurance policies and takes its fees on assets that every subscription swells. Five insurers sat for several years on the supervisory board.
The management company
Subscription fee, management fee on rental income, and since 2014 a disposal fee on every building sold.
The sponsor's shareholder
Crédit Mutuel Arkéa, parent company of Suravenir, bought into the Primonial group in 2014. Latour Capital and BlackFin followed as early as 2015.
Primopierre annual reports; decisions no. 14-DCC-84 and 15-DCC-105 of the French competition authority (Autorité de la concurrence).
In reality… Everybody won. And the point isn't to say that everyone should be paid on results. Nobody gets their croissant refunded if it's disgusting. But the customer may find it surprising that the baker brags about being loaded when everyone is eating disgusting croissants.
That's what happened in February 2024, when Primopierre's price fell from 180 to €168. 9 days later, on 22 February, Business Immo ran an interview with Grégory Frapet as its lead story. The headline is his55:
It was important to stress, he said, that Primonial REIM France had posted a satisfactory result in 2023.
Grégory Frapet, Business Immo, 22 February 2024
Of course the journalist who publishes that knows exactly what he's doing. And why he picks that sentence in particular.
Especially as Frapet is right. And the accounts say it better than he does: 2023 was the management company's best year for net profit over the period, €65.5M on €300M of revenue. The following year, revenue fell by 26.5%, and the firm still turned out €40.9M of net profit, a 28.6% EBITDA margin56. A margin of nearly 30% while the flagship product lost 45% of its value. How ironic.
But how can anyone utter that sentence in such a context, after billions in valuations wiped out, built on the real money of real savers?
Heads did end up rolling. Frapet was fired as chief executive in 2024, replaced by Marc Bertrand (ex-Amundi, ex-La Française, always in on the good deals), and Stéphanie Lacroix. Laurent Fléchet, for his part, stayed. But the group split. The Primonial brand, the asset savers knew, was sold to the Crystal group on 28 June 2024 along with the distribution arm. The management side, the one keeping the broken SCPIs, renamed itself Praemia REIM57.
So the question remains. How much did Primopierre's members pay for their investment to go from €3.4bn to barely €1.6bn?
What the manager took from Primopierre, by year (€M)
Subscription, management and disposal fees, as booked in the annual reports. Excluding reinvestment fees, transfer duties and works.
Primopierre annual reports 2009 to 2025.
See all the KPIs on the Zero Bullshit website (in French)
The €611.5M by type of fee, 2009-2025
Sum of the three fees in the previous chart, from 2009 to 2025. Subscription accounts for nearly three quarters: the manager makes money first and foremost when the money comes in.
Primopierre annual reports 2009 to 2025.
And that's just Primopierre.