💥 Zero Bullshit
Epilogue

Business as usual

So yes, Primopierre is a crap SCPI. No ambiguity. Run by a management team that got its vision completely wrong and took more than questionable decisions. While this investigation was being prepared, yet another testimony about Primopierre arrived through our tip-off platform (in French). The 15th or the 20th in 3 years. That of a man in his forties who was palmed off with more than €50K of Primopierre and Primovie in 2022 by an adviser who assured him it was a great investment. He signed the subscription form in early 2022, just as the war in Ukraine was starting. Through an adviser.

The objection is well known: it's not a loss until you sell. True. And it's not about to be sold. At a meeting for wealth advisers, a Primonial manager indicated that Primopierre would be locked up for at least 10 years. At least. The only hope, then, is to find some mug to buy back for 50 euros units that were sold for more than 200.

Meanwhile, several hundred people are paid by Primonial, at investors' expense, for what looks more and more like run-off management. Since nobody believes inflows will ever restart.

One of them, a former executive, actually came to complain to Zero Bullshit, starting by telling us to get off his back, then explaining his serious health problems after he left. And his difficult career change.

Let's be honest, his life has probably been less affected by his departure, after a full career in finance in senior positions paying 6- or even 7-figure salaries with bonuses and exits. But let's also be empathetic. All pain is equal, on no particular scale. This newsletter's attacks target the system and the mechanisms. People's private lives only come into it when they are necessary to understand an investigation. And we wish no misfortune or pain on anyone.

Still, as is often the case, as with SFAM, Aristophil, Benotmane, Villa (all in French) and the others, some people's accounting lines are other people's salaries.

What Primonial's fall tells us is less about a manager's poor vision, there will be plenty of others, than about the travesty made of what an SCPI was supposed to be. Members who buy together and pay a manager to take care of everything. That, incidentally, is what the battle over OPCIs in the mid-2000s was all about, when managers would have liked more freedom.

The most serious thing is probably that the regulator let it happen.

  • By gradually weakening the role of the supervisory board, for instance by forbidding it to influence management decisions;
  • By letting that same supervisory board get bogged down in conflicts of interest;
  • By allowing institutional investors to carry massive weight in the vehicles;
  • By keeping the same units for institutional investors as for retail;
  • By turning a blind eye to massive investments through opaque SCIs that the SCPI's members know nothing about;
  • By not regulating positions between vehicles of the same management company;
  • By regularly changing the performance indicators at the whim of the ASPIM, the industry's trade body, making long-term performance unreadable.

All of this gives the impression of a regulator that lets things happen, that doesn't understand, or that turns up after the battle, facing managers who have in any case already anticipated the next madness. And who, like the house at a casino, always win.

  • €611.5M for the house;
  • €1.7bn of capitalisation evaporated for the players.

And meanwhile, at La Défense, the workers are breaking concrete at the top of the tower. The top 6 floors of Cœur Défense are waiting for their Business Class tenants and their loggias for working between sky and city.

An exclusive experience that reinvents office property at La Défense, the sales pitch still promises.

The money from the records never leaves a trace in the brochures. It leaves one in the accounts. Somewhere between the 34th and the 39th floor, there's a loggia. It's up for rent.