💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 03

Montparnasse, the towering inferno

Previously on RX

After borrowing from various banks and approaching funds, in October 2020 Laurent Villa turns to crowdfunding. The €2M deal launched on Raizers aims to fund the opening of a Tribeca restaurant in Paris, inside Montparnasse station. A company, TMP, is set up a few days earlier, owned by Clav.

It is Villa’s first Parisian restaurant, presented as a project with Altarea, the landlord, which they say they reeled in thanks to the success of the Tribeca at Cap 3000 . With is a big word. Villa commits to a lease at €600K a year excluding VAT: a far cry from a joint venture. But hey, that is how PR works.

The Raizers financing, over 60 months at 7%, lets him repay in instalments of 25% from the 2nd year, against his personal guarantee and his partner’s, a first-demand guarantee (GAPD) on Clav, and a pledge over a business… that does not exist yet. According to the documents I have seen, the project had a budget of €4.7M, including €500K of working capital and €4.2M for the works:

  • €3.5M in Raizers bonds;
  • €1M in equity;
  • €200K in subsidy from Altarea, the landlord.

Except that Raizers ends up raising only €2M, the minimum needed to close the project.

Shortly before signing the raise, in March 2021, Laurent Villa announces in the Tribune Côte d’Azur a €4.5M raise to develop RX, notably its industrial side and Tribeca8, of which I have found no further trace.

But a few months later, in November 2021, Laurent Villa raises €15M for RX Venture through SquareStones, which brings together 7 Swiss investors, to finance two separate projects:

  • Opening the Tribeca restaurant at Montparnasse;
  • Financing a 4,000 m² factory in Mouans-Sartoux, near Cannes, for RX Industries.

Use of funds of the bond loan subscribed by the SquareStones pool.

In reality, it is a €15M financing in three tranches.

While the deal provided for three tranches of €5M, he ultimately receives only €3.4M to begin with.

Then, the following year, in 2022, Laurent Villa appears about ten times on Tudigo, for property projects (which will get their own newsletter), and three times to finance Tribeca restaurants.

The problem is that by 2025, every one of these restaurants has closed:

  • RX Industries, which held the Mouans-Sartoux factory, has been liquidated;
  • Tribeca Marseille never opened;
  • Tribeca Toulon neither;
  • Tribeca Montparnasse even less so.

Asked about it, Laurent Villa blames, in turn, Covid, the investors, the banks, his former partners or his landlords. But the dates do not really add up.

Because in October 2020, when he arrives on Raizers, Covid has been around for months. When he raises through SquareStones, the last lockdown ended 6 months earlier. And when he raises on Tudigo, it is already the end of 2022…

Reality seems more prosaic: on top of the problems already mentioned, the group was already in trouble.

Lease explain

The first thing that jumps out about the financing of this project is that the three borrowers are different:

  • On Raizers in 2020, it is TMP, a subsidiary of Clav;
  • At SquareStones, it is RX Venture, set up in 2021, a subsidiary of Be@liv, which therefore has no ownership link with TMP, apart from a shared shareholder and director;
  • At Tudigo, the marketing material talks about a restaurant that is a subsidiary of RX Retail, itself a subsidiary of RX Green Venture… which in fact means RX Venture, since RX Green is a subsidiary of RX Venture.

EDIT 5 August 2025, 9.30am: a document received after publication shows that at the end of 2022, TMP was 70% owned by RX Venture.

But there are two other details that catch my eye in the contract between TMP and Raizers9.

Extract from the contract between TMP and Raizers.

As they say, the devil is in the detail.

  • First point: the decontamination works. The contract uses the past tense, seeming to indicate that the works are finished. But in July 2023, Laurent Villa tells Raizers that these works delayed the project by 8 months, then by 20 months because of administrative disputes with the town hall.
  • Second point: the lease. You might think it is a standard commercial lease. Asked specifically about this, Villa confirms to me orally that it is indeed a 9-year lease, then in writing that it is the one provided in the financing files.

Here is the lease Laurent Villa presented to Raizers, signed by Frédéric Laloum of Altarea:

  • 9 years, renewable, with compensation if renewal is refused;
  • €600K a year, excluding VAT and service charges;
  • 4-month rent-free period;
  • Stepped discount (€200K in year 1, €100K in year 2);
  • €150K first-demand guarantee.

The lease presented to Raizers.

But it is not the real lease.

Laurent Villa handed over a fake: what he actually signed, on 31 July 2020, was a short-term lease of 3 years.

I obtained the real lease, and was able to confirm it is genuine.

The lease actually signed.

This 3-year short-term lease, outside France’s protected commercial-lease regime, came with a side letter from Sorac, an Altarea subsidiary, allowing a 10-year extension, 6 years of them fixed, if the restaurant’s turnover reached €4.5M excluding VAT.

The side letter from Sorac.

From then on, the rent would rise to €635K a year excluding VAT and service charges + 14% of turnover excluding VAT.

This is obviously no small detail, since it also made the pool of Swiss investors at SquareStones wince.

Off the record, a member of the group tells me he would never, ever have invested in the project had he known about the lease. Because it means the lease ended on 30 July 2023, leaving Laurent Villa 19 months to finish the works, open and make €4.5M in turnover. Which is clearly unrealistic.

At Tudigo, the analysts had indeed received the short-term lease, which, between the raise at the end of 2022 and the end of the lease, had… less than a year to run. So one is entitled to ask: how could such a project ever be approved?

The short-term lease is signed

Three years, until the summer of 2023. A side letter extends it by 10 years if the restaurant makes €4.5M in turnover.

Raizers: €2M

Over 60 months. The contract presents a 9-year lease.

SquareStones: €15M signed

In three tranches. Only €3.4M arrives.

First coupons unpaid

At Raizers, November then December.

Tudigo: €750K

For works that never started, less than a year before the end of the lease.

Sorac terminates the lease

Citing the €2.2M owed by three other restaurants.

End of the short-term lease

The restaurant never opened.

And clearly, for Laurent Villa, it is no small detail either. He was not very keen for it to get out. Because when he has to respond to the lawsuit brought by the SquareStones investors, he writes:

[Eric] Agnetti is the lawyer for Laurent Villa and his companies in several cases, notably those against the SquareStones investors, late 2023

Note: I hesitated for a long time before taking the legal risk of publishing this image, since it breaches the confidentiality of correspondence. But these messages are not a communication with a lawyer, are not part of any investigation as far as I know, and are clearly in the public interest, since they illustrate a lie that plainly harmed investors, in the context of a public offering.

In reality, Sorac terminates TMP’s lease in May 2023, citing the €2.2M owed by three other restaurants. And here we get into a (once again) slightly technical subject.

When Laurent Villa signs the Montparnasse lease, TMP does not exist yet. The contract states that Laurent Villa was to be a shareholder and officer of the company to be set up.

The tenant on the Montparnasse lease.

Which Altarea disputes after the fact, arguing that Villa is neither a director nor a direct shareholder, but the 85% beneficial owner via Clav. For his part, Villa argues that Sorac is taking a decision based on unpaid debts of separate, legally unrelated companies. Which is true… or not.

  • On the unpaid debts
  • Tribeca Cap 3000 belongs to Group Clav;
  • BeefHouse Toulon too;
  • BeefHouse Aix is a special case, co-founded by Jean-Christophe B. and Gabriel Villa (Laurent’s father), but seems to have ended up in BHI Finance’s pocket, probably when the IP Box was set up.
  • On the lease
  • If we decide it sits in TMP, financed by Raizers, then it is a subsidiary of Clav, so we are indeed in the same group;
  • If we decide it sits in RX Venture, financed by Tudigo, then there is no longer any ownership link between the unpaid debts and the lease.

Still, it is really less a question of ownership links than of broken trust between an entrepreneur and a partner.