Laurent Villa says he has sued Altarea for €2.4M in damages for wrongful termination of the Montparnasse lease. But the companies’ history shows a great many unpaid bills across the whole group. At the BeefHouse Toulon, in the L’Avenue 83 shopping centre (landlord: Altarea), several other invoices went unpaid, including one of almost €150K for works… dating from 2016, when the restaurant opened. Six months after the job, the company EGCM, left unpaid, even ended up in liquidation, and the liquidator clearly pointed to that job as the direct cause of the default15.
The same story is playing out at the same time at the Tribeca Marseille, run by Seven FR, which Villa calls the group’s flagship. According to my information, here again, €1.6M of unpaid rent owed to Hammerson. In a dispute with a neighbour over a leak that has dragged on for months, the restaurant struggles before signing a new lease in the summer of 2022, cutting the arrears to €600K. But when it comes to signing, Villa challenges the lease to avoid paying the million-euro entry fee.
Same thing at the Mon Grand Plaisir shopping centre in… Plaisir, west of Paris: the Tribeca restaurant that opened in 2019 receives a formal demand for €283K in January 2022, then a lawsuit to terminate the lease.
That is more than a year’s rent.
A few months before the three raises on Tudigo.
Seven is ordered at first instance to pay its €450K in rent arrears (time flies…) plus compensation for occupying the premises. Tribeca finally leaves in April 2024, after more than €1M of unpaid rent. It is getting hard to blame Covid for that.
As for the BeefHouse Grenoble, opened inside La Caserne de Bonne, a shopping centre, the lease is taken in mid-2015 and for three years no rent is paid16. Then the works are abandoned. In 2020, though, there is still talk of an opening17, but the permit only arrives in August 2021, and the restaurant soon closes. When it closes, not a single rent payment has been made, leaving the landlord with a €1.3M tab. Or a brewer with €17K of invoices left unpaid, even before Covid.
List of unpaid bills.
Or again at the BeefHouse Lille, which shows €840K of arrears in November 2021, just as all the raises are coming in. Here again, Laurent Villa cites Covid, but the landlord, Westfield, shows that the arrears dated from… before Covid18. So BeefHouse is evicted.
And the story repeats itself many, many times:
Laurent Villa then defends himself by explaining that Covid was not just lockdown, but more broadly changes in behaviour, in shops and cinemas, that brought down footfall in shopping centres, and therefore his figures. Except that is precisely what the marketing material circulated on Tudigo says.
The Tribeca Toulon in the Tudigo documentation.
These arrears probably help explain why the two other projects financed on Tudigo, besides Tribeca Montparnasse, never happened. In both cases, the plan was to turn BeefHouse restaurants, on the Clav side, into Tribeca restaurants, on the RX Venture side.
Did the BeefHouse Toulon’s arrears to Altarea sink the project? In any case, they existed before the raise on Tudigo, and kept growing until July 2024, when the restaurant closed for good. Either way, the works never seem to have taken place, as a manager at the shopping centre confirms to me.
He tells me he was not aware of any works, let alone of a change of brand on the shopfront.
Same story for the Tribeca Marseille. The BeefHouse closed its doors in July 2022 and never changed brand. Here again, a manager at Terrasses du Port, the shopping centre, is categorical:
According to him, when the BeefHouse closed, its window was covered with Tribeca stickers, but nothing ever happened after that.
So we have €1.75M raised on Tudigo that not only never led to a restaurant opening, but where one can seriously wonder where the money went. Asked that question, Laurent Villa answers without hesitation:
The funds raised, he says, were intended for the projects to be financed.
An answer that leaves one puzzled, because in the property files (which we will come back to soon) Laurent Villa readily explains that funds travel from company to company and are pooled through a (perfectly legal) cash-pooling agreement.
That said, a troubling coincidence might suggest otherwise.
A few days after Christmas 2021, the 55 Raizers investors get the nasty surprise of discovering that the November coupon, then the December one, have not been paid. Laurent Villa plays the Covid card, again. Fine. Except the delay goes on…
In February 2022, only half the interest is paid. Laurent Villa promises the balance for March, then for June. Payments trickle in, always late, always incomplete. The excuses pile up. Notably the considerable delays, according to a message sent out by Raizers:
Even though the decontamination was supposed to have been done already, and the works to be carried out by Laurent Villa, notably through his company BuildUp, never started.
Payment becomes almost a running gag in the messages Raizers sends its investors, a classic sadly found in a great many crowdfunding files, where project owners very often choose to keep digging.
Then suddenly, on 12 November 2022, Villa pays €500K in one go: his first instalment. Where does this money come from, when the restaurant is still not finished and the operating company is not making a single euro? Oddly enough, the money arrives a few weeks after one of the raises on Tudigo.
Asked specifically about this transfer, Laurent Villa this time explains that the cash is pooled through RX Venture, and that this €500K is therefore not necessarily Tudigo’s. Money has no colour.
According to him, this money, raised for the Tribeca Marseille, was meant to buy back the business. Which belonged to Seven FR / Clav. Which suggests a kind of operation in which all the assets were taken out of the Clav / BHI branch to be rebuilt on the RX Venture branch.
This behaviour could be explained by the fact that the Seven / Clav branch took on a fair amount of debt coming out of Covid, notably in PGE, France’s state-guaranteed Covid loans. €2M with the CECAZ, the Caisse d’Épargne Côte d’Azur savings bank, alone.
Reconstruction of the bond debts owed to the Caisse d’Épargne Côte d’Azur.
* First instalment or first tranche unpaid.
** Principal, interest and penalties as at 5 December 2023 (or the nearest date given).
The bank eventually calls in the guarantees of Laurent Villa and Chloé Albertini, who, in exchange for part of the debt being written off, agree to pay €900K before 31 December 2024. A debt that in fact covers only the companies’ overdrafts and loans, and in no way the PGE, whose losses the bank does not even try to quantify, and which will probably end up in a claim with Bpifrance, the French public investment bank, which will reimburse the bank 90%. Whatever it takes, as the French president put it.
Did the various investors know about these arrears?
Asked whether, when the Swiss investors signed in December 2021 and Tudigo signed in mid-2022, some companies already had unpaid loans, Laurent Villa replies:
In all honesty, he says, he does not think so, and he does not understand my question, which might imply that he hid something from the Swiss investors. He reminds me, with three exclamation marks, that he has sued them for €76M in damages. Investors of that kind, he adds, do not act lightly, and they carried out all the prior audits themselves before investing.
According to other sources, La Banque Postale and Société Marseillaise de Crédit are also said to have granted PGE loans to several entities, including BeefHouse Marseille and BeefHouse Group.
There are also many security interests linked to leasing agreements, which is fairly standard, or to businesses:
The same register also shows some of the social security and tax bills left by the companies:
The fact remains that the sum negotiated with the CECAZ was not paid on time. According to Laurent Villa, the matter was settled in May 2025. How?
According to him, the Caisse d’Épargne had taken provisional mortgages on Chloé Albertini’s property.
Which property remains to be seen. Because, as we will see in the next episode, the line between what belongs to Albertini and what belongs to Villa is not always very clear. What is clear, however, is that in 2024, the CECAZ applies to seize the shares of Casa Isula, which owns a villa in Corsica (more on that in… you know the drill).
The provisional pledge over Laurent Villa’s shares.
The pledge becomes final in May 2025.
The final pledge.
But as of today, it no longer appears in the register of security interests over movable property, which seems to indicate that the debt has been paid. Moreover, a capital increase has left Laurent Villa with a very small minority stake, and as of today the beneficial owners of Casa Isula are Chloé Albertini (46.55%) and her brother Vincent (48.45%).
As for who paid, and when… There is no way of knowing whether Laurent Villa paid out of his own pocket, or whether yet another internal transfer took place.
This system of pooled money movements is Laurent Villa’s trademark, and it turns up everywhere. Take the conversion of the BeefHouse Cannes into the Tribeca Cannes.
In April 2022, at a board meeting, Villa announces the conversion of this restaurant, with its 350-seat terrace on the Allées de la Liberté, which is also the name of the company, targeting €3.5M in annual turnover. The site reopens on 15 March under the Tribeca label, presented as one of RX Venture’s major milestones.
Extract from the minutes of a meeting
The accounts tell a different story. At 31 March 2022, RX Venture’s intercompany accounts show a €1.1M receivable from the company Tribeca Cannes, described in substance as:
a subsidiary of RX Retail, whose shareholder is RX Venture; a subsidiary at 5%, then 49%.
Balance sheet of RX Venture
Except that the company Tribeca Cannes does not exist. Six months later, the Tribeca Cannes receivable disappears from the accounts, replaced by a €1.22M line on a company called Allées de la Liberté, which does indeed run the BeefHouse Cannes, but has no ownership link whatsoever with RX Venture, since it belongs to Chloé and Vincent Albertini.
Accounting entries of RX Venture
As of today, it is in fact the only restaurant still open.