💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 04

Beyond Reasonable Doubt

The leaked data includes almost all the first and last names of the clients and prospects of the IFAs who use Harvest, plus nearly 100,000 email addresses, of professionals and end clients, and a host of details already covered in Le Brief Patrimonial (in French), a newsletter for wealth professionals. Which inevitably has the industry gritting its teeth. But could there be something else?

The true extent of the attack is still hard to pin down today. Because Harvest has kept its communication with clients to a minimum, but also, possibly, because the company doesn’t necessarily know whether the hackers hold other data. Or has no intention of saying so publicly without confirmation.

But here is what is known, and the various current hypotheses:

  • ✅ Ransomware was deployed on the internal network at Harvest’s head office, encrypting all or part of the data, which became unreadable for Harvest but was taken by the hackers.
  • ✅ All or part of that data was released by the hackers on 11 April, shortly after being sent directly to a number of outlets, including Zero Bullshit, because Harvest refused to pay the ransom.
  • ✅ Run Some Wares used information contained in the stolen data to try to break into Harvest’s application servers and into some of its clients.
  • ❌ So far, everything suggests that no client has been hacked.
  • ✅ Run Some Wares put a database up for sale, which was quickly taken down.
  • ❓ The few-line extract of that database suggests it could be the O2S one, but:
    It could simply be an extract sitting on a computer, rather than direct access to the server;
    I have not been able to verify the data in the extract;
    The hackers have not said why the sale was withdrawn.
  • ❓ Run Some Wares hinted in a message that it holds other data.
    That could be other files from the internal network;
    But why not also databases from the application servers, whose data is obviously highly sensitive. And worth a great deal.

Because you have to understand what lies behind this hack. I’ll admit I was very surprised when Harvest quickly said there was no cause for concern. Hackers of this calibre don’t attack at random. And companies like Harvest aren’t targeted by some mere act of vandalism meant to crash the software. If the hackers got in… it wasn’t to leave empty-handed.

We won’t go back over all of Harvest’s comms, already detailed in Le Brief Patrimonial (in French), but you can see it doesn’t add up. Same story for the op-ed by Vincent Couroyer (which reeks of ChatGPT), even though he heads innovation at the CNCGP, a French trade body for IFAs21. In an op-ed in CityWire, he explains:

In Harvest’s case, he argues, the fact that the hacked data was released on the dark web so quickly shows that it found no buyer; sensitive as it is for professionals, it has little value beyond their business, which should reassure them about the consequences of the attack.

That’s wrong three times over. And I’ll admit I’m baffled that, two months on, everyone’s communication is still so wide of the mark.

  • If the data was published, it’s not because nobody wanted to buy it. That data was never for sale. It’s because Harvest chose not to pay the ransom22.
  • The fact that this data was published in no way means that other data, data with value, isn’t for sale. Or hasn’t already been sold. Just imagine the O2S database, with hundreds of thousands of qualified, affluent, high-earning clients. Imagine what data like that could be worth…
  • At no point should this attack reassure anyone! It’s completely crazy to say something like that. There is now very precise information about private individuals out in the wild that can be used to set up large-scale scams. We’ve seen the consequences with every leak in recent years… Claiming that kind of thing shows a serious lack of knowledge of the subject.

Because on top of the usual personal data, which leaks almost daily, we are dealing here with explicit and very precise data such as investments, account numbers and transactions.

Sure, nobody cares that so-and-so invested such-and-such an amount. But we’ve seen how the leaks at Free, a French internet and mobile operator, for example, allowed call centres to be set up where scammers posed one after another as bank advisers, simply by linking a name and a phone number, made credible by the bank (thanks to the IBAN) and the address. Or any other detail that serves to say “look, I’m not a scammer, I know things”.

So imagine what can be done with information this precise... With client numbers, file numbers, amounts, contact details, names of IFAs or advisers and so on. And this is obviously in no way an invitation to go and scam people: those who do it for a living don’t need my tips and tricks.