💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 03

The Phantom Takeover

If Benotmane refuses to say clearly what he sold, he also refuses to say clearly who bought it. And that is downright astonishing. Because entrepreneurs who pull off exits are plentiful. Exits above €50M are rare. Above €100M, they rarely go unnoticed. But in almost every case, we know who is behind them.

If anything, the announcement is always about the buyer, even when it isn’t well known. Even when it’s a fund only professionals have heard of. Frankly, I have never heard of an eight-figure deal in which the buyer was (and stayed) a secret.

Still, on several occasions there is talk of BNP Capital, which supposedly either became a shareholder or acted as an intermediary.

From an article in the daily Le Parisien

The problem is that BNP Capital doesn’t exist. And never has. Better still: of the dozen or so people I was able to speak to at BNP Asset Management or BNP Développement, nobody had ever heard of this deal. Nor had anyone at the handful of investment banks that might have handled it. But then, nobody is omniscient.

To prove the sale, Benotmane therefore puts forward this document, since deleted, which he says was authenticated by a bailiff (in France, a court officer who can formally certify documents).

Document posted by Benotmane, since deleted

Reached by phone, the bailiff answered me in a few seconds, before hanging up:

She had no comment to make, she said, wished me a good day and said goodbye.

Fairly irritated. Probably already in the loop. And at any rate not denying that she had indeed authenticated something.

So what we have here is:

  • 57 restaurant premises;
  • 51 restaurants, 8 of them with 30% partners;
  • 72 franchisees;
  • 25 restaurants he would keep.

As for the financial terms:

  • The company’s valuation is said to be €117M;
  • The payment, meaning what he receives, is said to be €52M;
  • With a possible earn-out of €8M, on conditions we don’t know.

Which in itself is already 50% less than what he has always said, since without those conditions he would only have received €52M. And so did not make an exit of more than €100M, as he keeps saying everywhere.

But let’s assume.

The document, on the other hand, looks rather thin. That a deal of this kind should have only six definitions is strange. Stranger still, neither the seller nor the buyer is mentioned, not even redacted, and it is even more curious that the contract refers to the Company without ever defining who it is: the introduction only mentions a top holding company whose name is redacted, without ever saying that it was the one being sold.

Another oddity: it mentions an OBO (an owner buy-out, in which an owner sells his company to a holding company he still controls), supposedly carried out earlier, for €48M. Which doesn’t seem consistent with a group that appears to have been structured in cascade very early on, whereas an OBO would suggest a recent restructuring.

And so Hakim explains that the bailiff certifies all this.

Except that the bailiff doesn’t say that. What the bailiff says is that she:

  • saw an OBO contract dated 1 January 2013, while specifying that she could not see the name of the entity;
  • saw a sale agreement with the parties masked, dated 12 February 2014.

Not to mention that the valuation itself raises questions.

So nobody can know… except the state.

Because as someone or other once said: nothing is certain except death and taxes.

And I can state without the slightest shadow of a doubt:

Hakim Benotmane never carried out an OBO in 2013;
Hakim Benotmane never sold his company in 2014, or afterwards.

In keeping with this story, he also claims to have been among the richest people in France, and says on his LinkedIn banner that he was France’s 500th richest person at the age of 29, so around 2014.

I put the question to Éric Treguier, who publishes La Minute Riches, also on Substack, but who also created the 400 Fortunes ranking for the French weekly Le Nouvel Économiste in 1994, and above all was deputy editor-in-chief of the business magazine Challenges from 1996 to 2023, where he created and ran its famous ranking of France’s 500 biggest fortunes. Hard to find a better expert on the subject.

To be 499th, he explains, you don’t need €100M of valuation but more than €200M. Benotmane was never in the ranking, obviously, he says, and if he isn’t, it is because Treguier never found any official accounts or anything at all belonging to him, nor the slightest proof of any deal of the size he was claiming.

This year, in a podcast with Oussama Amar, which tells you how serious it was, Benotmane described some tax optimisation or other towards Switzerland, without explaining why he would have done that when both his holding companies are in Luxembourg.