💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 02

Halo Effect

Memory is a living thing, and not always a reliable one. I was thinking that a few days ago, realising that I have been writing on the internet for exactly twenty years, and that some friends I went to a concert with at the Bataclan, in Paris, never came back, exactly ten years ago.

So if Benotmane usually says the company was sold in 2014, you can see why the FBH Groupe website gives 2016 as the year a new shareholder arrived, and why he himself sometimes gives that date.

That said, the detail raises questions. Because in February 2016, HB Holding, where he had placed several restaurants, raised €300K on the Belgian crowdfunding platform Look&Fin.5 The deal came with an official announcement stating that:

Hakim Benotmane currently runs 53 outlets, 45 of them franchised, according to the announcement.

The following month, he announced a €5M fundraising round for the franchise, described as the Nabab group renamed FBH Food, from 123 Venture. 6 By then the talk was of 81 outlets, 63 of them in France, 18 of them company-owned. That is 28 extra outlets opened in six days. Benotmane explained at the time:7

This financial partner, he said, would let the group borrow far more from the banks and speed up, not only with Nabab but also with nearly a dozen brands it was launching, all of them halal.

Problem: 123IM (the new name of 123 Venture) formally denied this to me:

123 Investment Managers, the firm told me, has never backed or financed Mr Hakim Benotmane or the companies he runs, and no business relationship was ever initiated.

I don’t think it could be any clearer.

That said, there is talk of a move to Asia from 2016 to 2020. So you could imagine a sale in 2014, followed by a transition period, and journalists misunderstanding the fact that he was running the business without necessarily owning it. It’s possible.

To a banking partner in 2022, he tells another story, in the third person

In 2013, the account goes, fed up with his repeated battles, he decided to go and do something else abroad. His banker at LCL, a French high-street bank, had told him he would already have made his first billion if he had chosen a business other than kebabs. Kebabs and the halal market, it goes on, were frowned upon in 2003, unlike today, when they are becoming a juicy business.

As for the Asian chapter, while he often says he set up a chain of cafés, not one of which has ever been found, he gives that same banking partner another version, talking about the FitFit venture, which we’ll come back to in the second episode.

From 2014 to 2018, he writes, he was abroad, thinking hard about FITFIT: the idea was to move into digital, where sales could be global. He kept a distant eye on the restaurant group, he adds, and came to France once a quarter.

The problem is that this period is a bit like the job candidate who can’t explain the gap in his CV to HR. Because on one side he has to protect the supposed sale, in which he was no longer in charge, and on the other the fact that, as we’ll see, he never really left. Which is what the investment director of a private equity fund, approached to invest in FBH Groupe, wrote in a note in 2022:

He asks what happened between 2017 and 2019. As he understands it, Hakim actually came back to run the business full time, at 100%, in 2019, a year in which he was very busy. He asks for more detail on the sequence: he understands the new CEO arrived in 2014, and the fund thought Hakim had taken back the reins in 2017. He asks Hakim to say exactly when he ousted his CEO, and, since Hakim had told him in 2018 that he had another business, to shed some light on that.

The question will go unanswered.

Which raises another question: what was actually sold?

Here again the stories diverge. And wildly: he is less a storyteller than a franchise of stories.8 What Benotmane says, roughly,9 is that he sold his group for between €100M and €120M, with a property side for the premises and an operating side with the businesses and the brands. Sometimes to German funds, sometimes British, Anglo-Saxon or Turkish ones (or several at once), with the involvement of BNP Capital.

From the website of FBH Groupe

In his various public statements, Benotmane says his sale had two parts: the restaurants and the premises. In reality, it’s a tiny bit more complicated than that.

Because Benotmane’s idea is as simple as it is brilliant: find restaurant concepts that can be copied, then copy them in his own group, as franchises, while investing in the premises.

Because Nabab isn’t exactly innovative as a franchise. In reality, it’s kebab meals like you find everywhere. Tacos King, for its part, would copy the menus of O’Tacos, the market leader at the time, item for item. A closeness, right down to the brand name, that earned Benotmane a lawsuit, which a short-lived manager settled for €50K. A sum Benotmane never paid to O’Tacos, according to two concurring sources, one on each side of the deal.

The same kind of case was brought by the operator of the Le Tacos de Lyon brand, created in 1999, which sued NDM Développement but came too late, after the liquidation.10

Later on, the method for brands was even standardised:

  • Hire a network manager;
  • Who arrives with the recipes and the standards manual;
  • Fired after a few months, once the know-how has been absorbed.

At least two cases are documented.

But the truth is that FBH looks like one of those pretty McKinsey PowerPoints, shown from meeting to meeting, from team to team. Excellent on paper, but worthless if nobody knows how to roll it out. All the more so since FBH would end up holding… 44 concepts and brands.

Poulet P&P Chiken, Nabab, Rixos, O Tandori, Takos King, Woky Thai, P&P, Poke & Moi, Hill’s Coffee, Le Brunch de Kelly, Salade Factory, O Cheese Nan, Five Burger, Biggy Burger, My Bagel, Pizza Tchika, Bakim’s Café, Food Court Hybride, Fish’ to Chip’s, Labanese, London Brunch, Soupe du Monde, Rice Box, Burricos, O Pepito, Sushiburri, 12 Eat, Crêpes & Shake, New York Factory, Asian Street Food, Choua, Helthy Juice, 66 Diner, Chef et Frais, Panino & Co, Tenders Party, Frypancakes, Le Sandwich Français, Le Pain et la Farine, Pat& Pizz, African Food, Bubble Dubble, Couscous Bowl, Bachta

Everything but the kitchen sink.

In reality, apart from a few Nabab and a few Tacos King, none of it ever got off the ground. The only brand that seems to exist is Bakim’s Café, a café on rue de Bordeaux in Tours, the city in central France Benotmane comes from, housed in the company BAB111, whose chair is a mysterious Luxembourg company called Ketary Food.12

But this kind of business only works as a franchise. That means having a few restaurants to establish the brand (and make sure it works), then selling it to franchisees who need support.

Which makes no sense at all across 44 brands when you barely have a handful of restaurants.

The structure itself, though, is fairly simple, even if it looks oversized and needlessly complicated:

  • Each franchised restaurant is held through a company owned by the franchisee;
  • Benotmane’s own restaurants are sometimes held by parent companies in France, such as Takos King Franchise13, itself held by TKPF14, held by FBH Holding15, held by NDM Developpement16, a Luxembourg holding company
    And the same through another branch, NDK, for Nabab;
  • The brands sit in NDM, to collect royalties;
  • The Belgian expansion goes through T.K.B. BVBA17;
  • The few premises sit in a few property holding companies (SCIs)18
    Two of which are held by Hakim (99%) and Farah, his sister;
    One by Lovel Invest (95%), a Luxembourg holding company that belongs to Benotmane, and Guira Wided (5%);
    Another held by Lovel Invest (95%) and 5% by Mostefa, Hakim’s father.

To keep it simple, there are two entities in Luxembourg, registered at Benotmane’s personal tax address:

  • NDM Développement for operations (where FBH Groupe sits), 100% owned by Benotmane;
  • Lovel Invest for the premises, which is reported to the tax authorities as 30% owned by Khadaja Bellahcene and 30% by Abdelmajid Bellahcene.

The story of Lovel Invest is a very odd one, by the way. Because the company was actually set up in 2009 by a wealth manager, for a Ukrainian who has since done business in Slovakia.

The company was quickly sold on to a family office through a Swiss tax adviser based in Luxembourg, before being taken over by the Bellahcene couple in 2012, already registered at Benotmane’s personal address.

So what exactly is Hakim Benotmane selling? Hard to say, since he sometimes claims to have sold the premises on one side and the businesses on the other, and sometimes the whole lot together. Whereas to Les Échos, he says clearly that it was FBH.

Either way, the reality is simple: between 2014 and 2022, a period during which these companies were more or less active:

  • The shareholding structure doesn’t change;
  • Hakim Benotmane remains registered as the beneficial owner of all these companies…;
  • …Which stay at the same addresses.

If Abdelkader Guetarni temporarily takes Benotmane’s place as manager, it is for a very specific reason. But Benotmane remains the owner of all the companies, which never change hands. As the many documents to come confirm.

And yet, in a recent video19 in which he claimed to be answering the “haters”, Benotmane shows a document supposed to prove the sale, which we’ll analyse further down, and which doesn’t give the name of the entity supposedly sold either. As if it were a state secret.

On 1 November, Benotmane attempted a would-be diversion by posting a company that was supposed to be a clue, blah blah blah. I won’t answer it to show that it’s false, but rather to show his (very poor) rhetorical tricks.

In reality there is no mystery:

  • It is the first company20, which ran his first kebab shop in Tours;
  • A company that was renamed S.I.D., then Dura et Compa;
  • Whose management he handed to Abdelkader Guetarni in 2013, which, as we’ll see later, is rarely a green flag.

While its business was indeed later turned into a holding company, it was liquidated like everything else in 2017. And no, it was never sold. The proof: in December 2014, Dura et Compa sued the operator who had taken over the Tours restaurant, alleging a breach of the lease-management agreement (a French arrangement in which a business is rented out to an operator), and ended up ordered to pay the costs.21

Neither the manager nor the beneficial owners had changed, obviously.

This triple diversion has been Benotmane’s classic pattern ever since he was confronted with his lies

  • The red herring: throwing something out there to muddy understanding, and above all to waste the time of those doing the explaining. Debunking always takes longer than asserting.
  • False balance: making out that there could be two versions of the same fact, or even a happy medium between them. No: asserting something false doesn’t make the truth any less true.
  • Gaslighting: manipulating the facts, often by making them needlessly complicated, to push those who read him, and those who heed him, into doubting themselves.

In short:
- Impossible to confirm exactly what was supposedly sold
- The company structure never changed after the claimed date of the sale
- FBH Groupe was never sold
- SARL Nabab was never sold
- None of the Luxembourg holding companies was ever sold