💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 04

Magic Holding

The reality is much simpler than the one Benotmane cares to tell: he simply stashed his assets in Luxembourg. Because the structure described just above dates from 2014, when Benotmane created NDM Développement. And that structure shows unambiguously that it never changed hands.

Although he temporarily appointed Issam Benali as director in 2016, he has remained the beneficial owner of NDM to this day.

So NDM owned 100% of FBH Holding when it was created in 2016, just as it did in its last filings in 2019.

But it also owns HB Holding, created by Benotmane in 2011 and held by NDM until its last filings.

Which itself held the 2 franchise companies, including TKPF here, and so on.

Quite clearly, there was never any sale, or any exit by Benotmane, of any kind.

2014 is simply the year he placed his assets in a Luxembourg holding company for tax reasons, while carrying on developing his brand.

As in June 2014, when HB Holding took over the business of the company Les Voiles for a restaurant in the Bouches-du-Rhône, near Marseille. The takeover included a €710K debt to BNP (Capital? 🥹). Benotmane created a company to hold the business, under HB, which took on the €446K still to be repaid, which BNP set out in a repayment schedule in October 2014.

And that is probably where the BNP story comes from: the bank did indeed finance several of the chain’s restaurants.

In 2014, for example, BNP granted an €82K credit line, guaranteed by HB, for a restaurant in Romans-sur-Isère run by the company Burger Romans. Barely a year later, the company stopped paying and the bank discovered a bankrupt business. Except that it also discovered that another company, NBA Drive, had taken over the business without telling the bank very much about it.

Same thing in Vigneux-sur-Seine in 2015, where BNP granted three loans to a franchisee who would run the restaurant into the ground in May 2017.22

BNP is also the lender for another restaurant in the Bouches-du-Rhône. In February 2017, an arson attack completely destroyed the Nabab. BNP called in the loan immediately, since there was no longer any business to secure the credit. SADA, the insurer, paid out €1M, but the company that held the business quickly went into court-supervised administration, which froze its debts. And when all this was raised, it turned out that the substitution had never been formalised, and that HB had simply protected itself. BNP managed, at the very last minute, to have the debt seized from the insurance payout.23

Because the reality behind the €100M lies is that the whole pyramid of companies collapsed between 2015 and 2018, during the period when Benotmane was supposed to be “in Asia”. Whereas a dozen accounts from people close to him and from franchisees place him very regularly around the restaurants.

Because, let’s be honest: who would put €100M on the table only to let their investment die so quickly?