The 52-minute rush on Green-Got is no miracle. It's actually a full-blown feat. Because before selling shares, Green-Got spent years building a community. And that community didn't build itself.
In reality, the pitch never said ‘manage your money better’. It says your money is a weapon, and that right now it's sleeping in oil, on the wrong side of the world. On one side the old banks that fund the drilling, on the other you, and a movement. “0 nouveau puits de pétrole.” [Zero new oil wells.]13 “The movement of a generation.”33 The customer isn't opening an account, they're joining a cause.
Everything in the brand serves that sense of belonging, from the little fox emoji 🦊 on social media to the wooden bank card. Wood is natural, and natural means good. Yet the plastic of a bank card was never the issue. The chip and the antenna stay, and that's where most of the footprint lies34. Asked several times, Green-Got's executives have never been able to put a figure on the difference in emissions between a plastic card and a wooden card35. An expert who has taken part in several studies on the impact of cards, interviewed by Zero Bullshit, goes as far as calling it a non-issue. Even a misconception:
In his view, it is all the more greenwashing because machines run all day long to produce plastic cards. Whereas with wood, assuming it really is wood with no protective plastic layer on top, production runs are necessarily short, and so emit more CO2 and consume more energy per card.
Expert who has taken part in several studies on the footprint of cards36
But a symbol needs no proof. And on top of this talisman against global finance, it's Mastercard that stamps its own symbol, in return for roughly €100K in subsidies in recent years2721.
The same gap between pitch and mechanics applies to the money itself. Green-Got swears your savings fund either the transition or oil. For the account, that's partly true: where deposits are channelled steers the money, because deposits are what make lending possible. Even if, in reality, you can't compare the carbon footprint of deposits at a Green-Got that can't lend with that of La Banque Postale or Crédit Mutuel, traditional French banks that use them to finance taxis, builders or industry.
For the life insurance policy, though, the financing is less obvious. Of the thirty or so funds in GG Planet, some are listed equity funds. And buying a share on the stock market means paying a seller, not the company, which doesn't see a penny of the transaction. The primary market finances, the secondary market merely moves the share from one hand to another. The saver thinks they're watering the forest; mostly they're buying already-planted trees from someone getting rid of them. It's not a lie, it's a shortcut.
Holdings of one of the GG Planet funds, managed by Dorval for Green-Got.
At the top you find AMD (3.4%), then Vertiv (3.2%, data centres), along with plenty of very large tech players such as ASML (chips). But also Legrand or Schneider, exposed to the energy transition, or Vestas and Nextpower, which produce or install green energy.
But this is an equity fund buying on the secondary market, so not a single euro funds the transition.
You find the same kind of exposure in another equity fund, at Pictet: TSM, ASML, Schneider, Siemens, Hitachi, and so on.
Holdings of a bond fund, managed by Mandarine Gestion, included in GG Planet.
This time, it really is money that finances companies.
Among the top exposures you find… BNP, along with 2 other banks, but also the luxury group Kering, or Iberdrola, one of Europe's biggest low-carbon energy companies, just like EDF.
Same hypocrisy on the structured side. Their issuers are precisely the banks Green-Got casts as the enemy: Crédit Agricole CIB for the first product, Citigroup for another, one of the world's biggest funders of fossil fuels since the Paris Agreement, $396bn between 2016 and 202337. They cash in as soon as the product is stamped sustainable. And the index underpinning the whole thing contains Nvidia, ASML or STMicroelectronics, anything but carbon-footprint role models, to finance assets whose substance nobody knows.
Crédit Agricole is bad. Except when it isn't.
The capital is guaranteed in the promotional email. Except when it isn't, in the regulatory documentation nobody will read.
Is it greenwashing? At bottom, and in the funds: no. The point of SRI (socially responsible investment) and Article 9 funds, the EU's ‘dark green’ label, was never to fund local farmers' markets or solar panels on schools. It was first and foremost to avoid exposure to problematic companies, and to steer money towards a sort of common-good capitalism. But let's not give Stérin, the French billionaire, any ideas.
The problem lies rather in the hard sell of words and pictures used by Green-Got, plastered with green, soil and trees, which suggest all that cash is going to save the baby pandas.
The star argument, the CO2 your savings supposedly weigh at a big bank, was examined closely, challenged by Bon Pote, and the consultancy that served as its scientific seal of approval, Carbone 4, withdrew its article10, confirming an earlier investigation here that had shown it in detail (in French).
Even so. Is Green-Got crap? Is sticking your cash with Green-Got a rubbish idea? Is your cash better off in an account at BNP, or paying for some dreary tower in La Défense, Paris's business district, through Primonial, the French property investment group? No, three times over.
And maybe if Green-Got didn't flirt with permanent greenwashing, it wouldn't have managed to weld a community around itself. Because let's be honest: climate change is here, the political debate isn't up to it, and finance, under its ESG and SRI labels, is still driven by inflows and short-term performance. The pitch is falsely radical, but it's sincere, and it speaks to people who are just as sincere. Enough to form the kind of active community every company dreams of. And to turn it into a growth engine, to the point that around a third of new accounts reportedly come through referrals.
The problem is that this makes a great small business that will speak to a few tens of thousands, maybe tomorrow a few hundreds of thousands, of people. Not a startup with a hyper-growth market to go after. And that's the whole problem with what was sold to retail.