Obviously, neither the New York tragedy nor C.’s story allows us to generalise or draw definitive conclusions. At most, they are symbols.
Even so, we are entering a period in which many finance, property and insurance professionals have to face up to their responsibilities. Not just over scams or would-be Madoffs. Those people have always existed. But as with every market reversal, accounts have to be settled. All the more so today, now that information is easier and easier to get hold of.
“You only find out who is swimming naked when the tide goes out.”
- Warren Buffett
Last July, an estate agent was found at fault4 for failing to display the energy performance certificate in a listing, using the (very common) line “certificate in progress”. Not the gravest of offences, but it was the 25th ruling against a property intermediary in 20245.
Even if the facts vary from one case to the next, the courts hold that property professionals do engage their liability in a transaction, something many seem to have forgotten during the crazy period when thousands upon thousands of self-employed agents piled into a booming market.
And it probably isn’t over. Because between 2023 and 2024, plenty of agents fought over listings in a flat market. To keep sellers happy, many overvalued properties they then failed to sell, or sold well below the initial price. According to a lawyer I consulted, fewer than five claims along those lines were filed by his firm in 2024 alone. A situation that had already led to a ruling against an agent in Rouen in 2021.10
I’m obviously leaving aside the rulings against crooked professionals or embezzlement cases. What is interesting here is rather the rise in rulings (and probably in proceedings) that hold professionals to account for their responsibilities and their advice.
Some will say that deregulating the trade, which lets self-employed agents work without an estate agent’s licence and after very short training, may have dragged down the quality of service. But can we really say the old high-street agencies were the gold standard?
The 1/3 - 2/3 split (in favour of sales through professionals) may be broadly stable over time, but it is mostly driven by older people, and for many of them, it’s because “that’s how it is and that’s how we’ve always done it”.
But in a market that is changing fast, in how the job is done as much as in the economic backdrop or what consumers expect, only those who prove their worth will survive. Not those who justify their fees by talking about their costs. Nobody gives a damn what your petrol or your VAT costs. The only question is: what does it bring the client? And so, is the price justified, for them?
The way some networks advertise could also become a problem. Some regulated professions (law, medicine) face very strict limits on how they communicate. Meanwhile, Stéphane Plaza and the French TV channel M6 managed to open more than 600 agencies thanks to a television show. Today those agencies are suffering both from a flat market and from the trial of their famous figurehead11.
Same story with the Kretz family and TF1/Netflix, whose 4 seasons of L’Agence, a reality show about the family’s luxury estate agency, did a great deal to legitimise their business. The broadcasters did not take a stake (unlike M6, which holds a majority in Plaza’s network), but the series helped the Kretz family build up more than a hundred self-employed agents today.
Yet these programmes are first and foremost scripted and staged, even though that is never clearly stated. There is no counting the debunks of fake deals or more-or-less-signed listings (on both shows). Enough to seriously distort competition.
Not least because M6 has also become a springboard for fintechs, which will be the subject of a future newsletter (yes, that’s a teaser, got a problem with that?).