💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 02

Little house on the Normandy prairie

Behind this unjustifiable murder lie hundreds of thousands, maybe millions, of injustices. Who hasn’t hit a wall of incomprehension with a health insurer, a welfare body or an insurance company, with no way of fighting back?

In reality, these small everyday stories are countless, and the vast majority of them go nowhere. No violence. No article. No lawsuit. Often not even a complaint, because everything is so complicated.

That is the case of C., a retiree I know well because she used to be my neighbour. Used to be, because a while ago she bought a house in the Normandy countryside. She first looks at the property from afar, then drives several hours to view it. Part of an inheritance, the house is in poor condition, but the listing states that it is connected to mains water, electricity and the sewer. At the 2nd viewing, the drainage survey on file says the outlets could not be located. Listed at €65K, the house is negotiated down by C. to €60K, and she plans the works and the move at the same time. Along with the move of her three horses, who will live on the huge plot of land.

But the story turns into a nightmare when her plumber wants to replace the very old water meter: the network operator says the house… is no longer connected to the new network. Same story from Enedis, France’s electricity grid operator: the outdoor installations are too old for the power to be switched back on. A temporary box and extension leads are put in. Even though the electrical issue had been explained between the last viewings and the sale.

The sellers say they never knew. Nor did the estate agent. Better still: he replies that C. bought the house as seen and has no recourse for hidden defects. Which is true if you read the deed of sale to the letter. And which the agent’s insurer would confirm, according to the agent himself.

Except it’s wrong.

An estate agent is liable for what he publishes in a listing. True, several sellers have already been ordered to pay for lying to an estate agent… but that was because the agent had been sued by the buyers.

That is the whole point of the Hoguet law1, which has governed the obligations of French estate agents since 1970. The duty to advise must sit at the heart of the relationship. As much for what is concealed as for what is asserted. All the more so because the agent’s civil liability is both contractual (towards his client, usually the seller) and non-contractual (towards a third party, usually the buyer)2.

After that, ordinary law does the rest: if there is a causal link between the fault and the damage, there is a right to compensation.3

In C.’s case, the false information had very heavy consequences:

  • 60 litres of bottled water brought in every day for the horses;
  • €4,500 for the water company to bring the network up to the property;
  • €2,000 to €4,000 to get the water into the house;
  • Probably the same amounts again for electricity.

So a little under €10K, not counting the obvious discomfort of living for more than two months in a home with no running water and on extension leads.

Whether the fault was deliberate or not makes no difference: claiming the utilities were available stopped C. from making arrangements in advance. And probably from renegotiating the price of the house, since we are talking about 10 to 15% of the price in unexpected costs.