But how can you talk about property intermediaries without mentioning financial ones? Here too, the market is booming. The CNCGP, a French association of wealth advisers, even reports a 32% rise in registered members over 3 years12.
Advisers rode the same wave of enthusiasm for investments as for property. The post-subprime frenzy and low rates pushed markets to stratospheric levels, bringing record inflows.
The problem is that for 95% of intermediaries, the client is not the investor but the manager of the financial product. Indeed, 95% of French wealth advisers and registered financial investment advisers are paid through retrocessions, in other words a percentage of the money they bring in. The remaining 5% charge fees13.
Inevitably, that raises the question of conflicts of interest: why would an intermediary offer the saver the best possible allocation if it takes far more time or pays less?
That probably explains why the gigantic inflows into SCPIs, French property funds sold to retail savers, between 2019 and 2022 were largely driven by these intermediaries. According to the figures (always extremely secret), between 10% and 60% of inflows come from the work of advisers or professionals.
You might also reckon that when the FNAIM, France’s main estate agents’ federation, and its little friends went all the way to the Conseil d’État, France’s highest administrative court, to demand that the cap on commissions (then 10%) on the Pinel scheme, a tax break for buying new homes to let, be lifted, it was not exactly in investors’ interest.14
Because selling a Pinel flat packaged by a developer, or SCPI units, is particularly easy for an intermediary. Whereas finding the right buy-to-let investment in an older property takes days and days, and is hard to make pay, judging by the number of property start-ups in the sector that have gone into liquidation.
Back in 2017, a wealth adviser and a developer were ordered to pay for selling a couple a real dud under Scellier, the tax scheme that preceded Pinel15. What the court mainly held was that the projection had been massively inflated, and that the monthly outlay exceeded what the investors could actually save.
Most rulings (once again, leaving aside the genuine scams) concern mandates that were not really respected, with an allocation far from what the client wanted.16
But on 20 November last year, the Cour de cassation17, France’s highest court, shed some light on the matter.
The case goes back to 2011, when a saver went to his wealth adviser to invest on a low-risk profile. The adviser suggested 70% in a capital-guaranteed euro fund and 30% in structured products, through an assurance-vie, the French life insurance savings wrapper, for €65K. Still on the adviser’s recommendation, the saver added €25K to the structured product, then switched the whole lot into Kairos, other, riskier unit-linked funds.
Except that a few years later, the investment is worth less than €4,000. The adviser explains that’s how the cookie crumbles, love, and that the markets have fallen, but the investor takes him to court. The court (and then the Court of Appeal) orders the adviser (and his insurer) to pay back €21.5K because:
The Cour de cassation confirmed all that… but in the end overturned the judgment because the life insurance contract had not matured, so the losses had not been realised. Which, for once, looks like a hell of an advisory error… by his lawyer.
The fact remains that the notion of advice, and the liability it carries, is now firmly established.