The vast majority of intermediaries believe they do their job properly. And, at the very least, want to do it well. But what do you say to the individuals who lost out?
Because, contrary to everyone who keeps talking about the supposedly aligned interests of clients, distributors and managers, reality says the opposite.
In substance: it is important to stress that Primonial REIM France posted a satisfactory result in 2023
That is what Grégory Frapet, head of Primonial REIM, a French property fund manager, was saying in 202418. What was really important were the gigantic falls in his funds, the result of a strategy of spending his giant inflows on a massive scale. Hundreds of millions of euros of individuals’ money went up in smoke so that Frapet could find it important to stress that Primonial was raking it in.
The same manager admitted in front of his distributors that, depending on the fund, the SCPIs would take more than 8 years to (possibly) get back to their pre-crisis level. While explaining that the property portfolio needed a massive overhaul, paid for, therefore, out of savers’ money.
Neither the manager nor the intermediaries will pay.
The point is not to blame finance for the losses.
Investing is risky.
And on the whole, the biggest managers, even those sanctioned for failing to inform investors, are not cowboys doing whatever they like with their marketing (unlike others we’ll come back to in a future newsletter, teaser no. 2).
But the arguments put forward by some managers or distributors were misleading (notably on office property), and so were the famous aligned interests.
The only way to align interests is for products to be paid on performance. Not on inflows. But the few who offer those models (Iroko first among them) or another way of doing things (Moniwan or Louve through cashback) regularly take flak from competitors who don’t like anyone going after the golden goose.
And yet it is by far the healthiest model.
If intermediaries really are capable of advice that has value, they will have no trouble getting savers to pay for that advice. Otherwise, why go through an intermediary at all, when the vast majority of products and services are now freely available?
This is not a philosophical or business-model question.
It is a question of professional survival.
My name is Benjamin Charles, and I do branding, positioning and content consulting for companies in finance, property and web3.
👉 Get in touch, or reply to this post: benj@mincharl.es
👉 Send me a brief for a business project
👉 Book a video call to present a project or a service (€300 per call)