💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 03

Free lunch for all

Out of more than 2,000 funds, I managed to trace more than 80014, liquidated or closed to new money, and analyse their performance by separating:

  • The fund’s performance;
  • The investment’s performance, including the tax advantage;
  • The annual IRR for liquidated funds.

While it isn’t possible to carry out a full market analysis, this 40% sample does allow a few conclusions.

  • The dotcom bubble didn’t kill the FCPI, which turned to the regions;
  • VCs’ massive use of the FCPI boosted the number of launches;
  • … and conversely, only 40 FCPIs were created in 2024

But of course it’s the performance (unquoted, as it happens) that is the most interesting part: it’s crap.

The vehicle’s average performance is -7%, and for the investor to get 5.5%, the State had to cough up the cash. That’s how Inter Invest’s FIP Outre-Mer 1, a fund for France’s overseas territories, shows 15% performance for the investor, while the fund itself does -23% over 5 years.

And the investment horizon is long… Which is what leads to an average IRR of 0.63% for an astronomical risk.

Only 292 of the FCPIs analysed show a positive gross performance, but among them:

  • 209 beat 10%
  • 146 beat 20%
  • 66 beat 50%
  • 23% beat 100%

And when you drill down another level, surprise surprise, the best-performing funds… come from the same managers.

Number of funds created (in blue) compared with performance (in orange). In red, 0% performance