💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 04

A crazy amount of dough

This scheme is one of many that let the private sector launder public money. Not in the sense that it’s illegal, but it lets partly public funds pass for entirely private ones.

In 2016, the Cour des comptes, France’s national audit office, published a scathing report on the ISF-PME scheme15, which cut your ISF, France’s wealth tax, when you invested in SMEs. It cost €620M at the time, or 11% of ISF revenue. Was it any use? Well, it’s all in the Cour des comptes’ first recommendation, which asks for its effectiveness to be measured regularly. Which, apparently, has never been done.

On FCPIs, the 9-page report pokes fun at their supposed benefits, notably the claim that they are more profitable than FIPs:

The Cour des comptes writes that this finding reflects the selection made by the management companies, which pick out the firms with the greatest growth potential, just as much as the effects of the investment itself. Since this gap in economic performance cannot be statistically attributed to the tax measure, it adds, these results should be interpreted with caution.

Along the way, the Cour des comptes lays into the management fees, which it describes as high: 4.5% a year on average, 1.8% of which goes to distributors, across its sample of 48 funds.

I ran the same kind of sample on FCPIs from 2023 and 202416, and management fees range between 2.8% and 4.4%, with an average of 3.15%, plus 5% (a figure that rarely changes) on subscription. Given that the investment horizon is 5-6 years, that comes to real fees of around 4% a year.

Since then, not a single report has looked at whether FCPIs are worth it, or given the slightest figure on what they cost the State.