💥 Zero Bullshit
Epilogue

Same findings, same outcome

Ever since the debates on the PLF, the French budget bill, began, aid for businesses startups has come up again and again. Nobody is saying the startup ecosystem is useless, or that the State shouldn’t put a single euro into it, but it would be good to ask some questions about public money.

A few weeks ago, I wrote about the hundreds of millions in public money burnt by the insect-farming startup Ynsect (in French). I was often told I didn’t understand a thing. That you don’t finance an industrial company’s capex the same way as a SaaS. And that, in the end, it was all perfectly normal.

But I never said Ynsect shouldn’t be financed.
I never said the company made no sense.
I never said there shouldn’t be a single euro of public money.

I raised the question of how much public money was spent (hundreds of millions) and how little monitoring and how few results were demanded in return.

Nobody can say a project is 100% going to succeed, otherwise capital would come flooding in. And the role of the State, in a country with neoliberal leanings like ours, is to support activities that are more or less critical.

So yes, funding breakthrough technologies like AI, where the country could miss out on a new internet-style revolution, or a more sustainable, long-term alternative for food, is not complete nonsense.

But public money remains a common good, so its effectiveness must be measured, and so the figures should be public. That’s actually the law, even if, as I explained last week (in French), getting them is hell.

For a few weeks now I’ve been watching Midy and his disciples cling to their tax breaks. It’s actually rather funny, and ironic, to see an ecosystem that leans mostly right-wing and free-market constantly calling for State intervention. I do understand that some companies depend on it.

But this famous JEI status that Private Midy is fighting to save: what has it actually delivered? Here again, I can hear the examples coming along with their lovely stories. But here again, yes again, a report by the Cour des comptes and INSEE17, France’s national statistics office, tells quite another story after 17 years of existence, finding a benefit for employment in only 16% of cases, and only after 2 years of existence.

Far be it from me to say it’s all bad, but you can’t say public money is well spent just because, well, from a distance, it looks cool.

Innovation is essential for the future and for our everyday lives. But the bulk of French companies are still SMEs that, without innovating, keep society running. They’re the ones taking the full brunt of inflation and rising electricity costs, and they can be badly destabilised by increases in payroll taxes or wages.

It’s not about saying there are good companies and bad companies. Useful ones and the rest. But the huge magnifying-glass effect of articles, funding rounds, unicorns and other media bullshittery, which lets elected officials show off, makes us lose sight of what matters.

To those who tell me I’ve understood nothing when I talk about Ynsect’s lack of profitability (who are in fact the ones who stopped at the headline, admittedly a bit provocative), I’d reply that of course you don’t make an industrial site profitable in a few years. But when I read that profitability isn’t a priority for a startup, or I see executives explaining to a commercial court that a startup isn’t a company like any other (spoiler: it always ends badly), I start to wonder whether part of French Tech (the part that gets the headlines) can build anything that lasts.

Why should a SaaS, whose funding rounds only finance its growth, and therefore hand cash to Google and Meta, enjoy so much public money, directly or indirectly? Why shouldn’t bakeries, IT installers or cleaning companies be entitled to the same advantages?

Or, to put it more plainly: aren’t we just slapping the startup label on anything with three potted plants, sweatshirts with a nice logo and a table football, purely to bag some tax breaks?

My name is Benjamin Charles, and I provide branding, positioning and content creation consulting for companies in finance, property and web3.

👉 Contact me, or reply to this post: benj@mincharl.es

👉 Send me a brief for a business project

👉 Follow me on LinkedIn

👉 Book a video call to present a project or a service (€250 per call)

You can also make a donation here. Pay what you like, and above all there’s no Substack taking 10% and Stripe 3% 😅.