Of the 13,866 funds approved by the AMF9, 9,798 are AIFs. In this big family you’ll find 223 good old SCPIs, 1,809 FCPIs and 229 FIPs, which work in a fairly similar way10, created by 267 different managers. Some are tourists who were just passing through, while others are out-and-out specialists.
Breakdown of managers by number of funds created11
34 managers have created more than 15 funds. At the top of the table is Amundi (89), followed by BPI (74) and UI Investissement (54), an SME financing specialist (€1.5bn AUM), Extendam (52), a hotel-industry financier (€4.3bn in assets), then LBO France Gestion (51).
That name will ring a bell with French Tech insiders: besides handling some high-profile deals (The Kooples, Mazarine), the manager backed a few proptechs. Among them Hosman, which went bust a few days ago, ZePlug, a member of the FT120 (the French state’s programme for 120 high-growth startups) that has just closed a slightly dodgy funding round12, and hemea.
So if you’re a smart cookie and you know the subject, you obviously saw where I was going with this, and for everyone else: yes, the FCPI is the vehicle VCs use in France. They hog the rest of the table: Eurazeo, IQ, Ardian, Turenne, Swen, Vatel, Tikehau, etc. Even if not all of them do VC exclusively.
Because in reality, when people talk about a VC coming into a funding round, it’s always through… a fund, funnily enough. I mentioned this in my newsletter on Masteos (in French), when talking about Yellow, one of Daphni’s funds.
So why am I frying your cortex with this FCPI business, and why do VCs use them?
Well, because, if you’ve been following from the start, we’re talking tax breaks. FCPIs and FIPs give you an income tax reduction whose rate has changed over time. If many funds have targeted Corsica, it’s because the tax reduction there reached 30% of the amount invested. With a cap, admittedly, but roughly speaking you could knock several thousand euros off your tax bill.
To understand the appeal of the product, I can’t resist citing MeilleurTaux13, a French loans and savings comparison site, which I think sums up the subject perfectly. And its problem:
MeilleurTaux explains that, though best known for its tax advantage, the Corsica FIP is nonetheless a rewarding investment. In a more pessimistic scenario, it says, any capital losses will be offset by the tax advantage, which makes the capital invested even safer, all the more so if you pick a tax-break product with a high tax reduction. If the fund’s performance excluding the tax advantage is 9%, it goes on, the final performance will be 21%, and negative performance will wipe out part of the tax advantage the fund offers.
In short, never mind if the products are crap, the taxpayer picks up the bill.
On top of that, after Covid, Emmanuel Macron raised the tax reduction to 25%, as he did for direct investment in SMEs under certain conditions. Enough to give a big boost to fundraising by these vehicles, which were also riding on the glossy image of French Tech, itself riding on free money.