💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 04

AMF: a Christmas wreath

Last 23 December, the AMF left 2 press releases nobody was expecting under everyone’s tree:

  • “L’AMF met en garde le public contre certaines plateformes proposant d’investir dans l’immobilier sous forme de « royalties »” [The AMF warns the public about certain platforms offering investment in real estate in the form of “royalties”]
  • “Activité des plateformes de partage de revenus futurs (royalties) : qualifications juridiques et réglementations applicables” [Activity of future revenue-sharing platforms (royalties): legal classification and applicable regulations]

In the 1st, everyone understands that Bricks is the target. The regulator warns investors, who it says are often very young, against a sales pitch it calls sometimes misleading. The tone is set.

The 2nd, more technical, basically says that royalty platforms must switch to a bond model. To make it clear:

  • Royalties: I buy something with your money, I run it, I keep some money to pay my costs, and I hand you part of the rest.
  • Bonds: I need money, you lend it to me, I pay you back.

Unlike bonds, royalties are not considered financial securities. Above all, if a bond defaults, the money is legally owed. Not with royalties.

The debate over legal classification still enthrals a surprising number of people (genuinely). While some still hope to keep royalties, especially the smaller platforms, the others are moving to the European status: the ECSP licence (European crowdfunding service provider, known in France as PSFP).

Even if you may end up wondering whether that status really suits what these platforms originally wanted to do.

Nobody expects the European regulation

Bricks had 3 options, which Cédric O’Neill sums up for me:

Keep the current royalties model and defy the AMF, as some are doing.

Go to an asset management firm to set up an AIF (my note: alternative investment fund), an SCPI and so on, but then, he says, they would lose the individual nature of each project and the gamification side.

Or turn the constraint into an opportunity: go and find outside project owners and become a peer-to-peer alternative to the banks.

It’s the 3rd option that wins: becoming a fintech. That means giving up what made Bricks, but in the end also what the company never managed to do well. Without bitterness, and with clear eyes, Cédric O’Neill tells me that financing their own projects was nice, but a sh💩tshow to manage and administer:

Often, he says, these are buildings that are profitable on paper: but if they are, it’s because there are day-to-day difficulties to deal with.

There is no such thing as a free lunch.

And speaking of opportunity, he sees another one: scalability. Because managing properties takes a lot of people. Whereas when you issue bonds, the borrower does the managing.

But getting the licence is no small feat, because there’s a subtlety in the spirit of the ECSP rules. As explained to me by an expert on the subject, a sharp technician and himself co-founder of a platform:

What ESMA (my note: the EU’s markets regulator, a European AMF of sorts) is really saying, he explains, is that it doesn’t have time to regulate everyone, especially small projects. The licence is a kind of delegated authority, where the provider acts as the link between project owners and investors. And its role is still to protect investors.

In fact, the regulation never mentions property. It talks about financing SMEs, startups and so on. But not property.

And yet, of the 15 licences granted, 12 went to property players. Among the others:

  • SoWeFund and Soul Invest, which fund startups
  • Enerfip, which funds energy projects

And that’s not counting the many other platforms (Bloks, Tantiem, Atoa, Katapult, Wincity, Brik and more) orbiting with a more or less identical model, some of which are seeking the licence.

But hang on: how does it work?

What’s all this, then?

It’s fairly simple: a project owner goes to a platform (the licensed provider) to fund a project. The provider checks how sound the thing is, then lists it on its platform. Investors put money in. Job done.

For indivisible, illiquid assets, article 3.6 allows an SPV (special purpose vehicle) to be set up: basically a company into which the investment is placed. It has become standard practice.

Bricks explains this structure very well:

What caused problems for Bricks, and for many other players, is article 8 on conflicts of interest: you are not allowed to fund your own projects.

The reason isn’t hard to grasp: the provider’s role is to analyse projects, make sure they are viable and give them its stamp of approval so investors pile in. If it approves its own projects, it won’t be on the investors’ side.

So Bricks restructured its entire business.

Until then, Bricks SAS (a French simplified joint-stock company) was a holding company with stakes in various businesses. So the group created a proper holding company and moved Bricks SAS underneath it, making it a sister of the others rather than their parent.

Which triggered the BSA AIR (France’s equivalent of a SAFE) from that famous fundraising, since the community vehicle had invested in the SAS. We then learned that Bricks was valued at €115M. That’s twice its assets under management (€54M). Hence an announced paper gain of 30%, which raises a smile in some quarters.

Bricks raised money at the height of the VC frenzy, and is announcing a 30% gain when it hasn’t brought in a euro for 6 months and the fintech market is at -60% over the same period, sighs a financial analyst who specialises in M&A.

But on top of restructuring, Bricks had to change its model: until now the company looked for properties to buy. Now it has to find project owners. Which is how Bricks’ 3 star hires had to be restructured too:

  • Sylvain Dumas, Chief of Real Estate Officer, hired to oversee asset management, property management and development work, has become Chief of Investiment and Loan;
  • Benoit Jamin, Chief of Property Development, in charge of the strategy for finding and acquiring properties, left the company in February;
  • Inès Dias, Country Manager Portugal, in charge of developing the Portuguese market, seems to be the only one whose job hasn’t changed.

And how convenient: the 1st “new model” project is in Lisbon!