💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 03

Opaque transparency

Every time he speaks, Cédric O’Neill, the platform’s boss, talks up his commitment to transparency. The problem: it rarely shows in practice.

Take the fees page, since removed: it was particularly misleading.

True enough: no subscription fee. But Bricks takes 10% of the transaction, built into the funding. And while they do take 1% of the property’s value a year for management, that can’t be compared with the 7-18% charged by SCPIs, which is taken on rent collected.

For several months, I published a tracker of every project, with its actual returns. Bricks would also end up taking the spreadsheet over, in the name of transparency, as it put it. Good idea (I’ll end up invoicing them for consultancy), but once again the figures used are misleading. Including in the document still being updated today.

When I explained that returns were inflated by 36% on average, Bricks replied that it was hitting 83% of its target. A respectable figure… but wrong, for 3 reasons.

  • It’s the average of each project’s “promised/paid” ratio, not the overall promised/paid ratio
  • The 3 projects that paid out nothing are left out of the calculation
  • The calculation sometimes starts 6, 8 or even 12 months after the fundraising… once the rent starts coming in

So the figure is artificially inflated: the real number is more like 75-78% of target.

Example: the return on Port Bonfim is calculated from May 2023, although the money was raised in November and the property bought in December.

So the figures on display, even in the name of transparency, aren’t very honest.

The real average return is 3.5%, not 5.02%

Last May, unable to understand why the price of bricks never went down, I once again analysed every property.

Surprise: they were being revalued… in whatever way suited Bricks! Sometimes even when valuations published on the platform pointed the other way.

A few days after I published, the errors were corrected.

Is this pile-up a kind of amateurism down to the company’s youth, as Cédric O’Neill sometimes explains, or a genuine intent to massage the numbers?

Make up your own mind. But one thing is certain: it’s mainly down to disastrous property management. Cédric O’Neill half admits as much to me.

Bricks, he says, took on residential property in mid-sized towns, with individual tenants to manage. Sometimes there are shared meters, which makes service charges hard to handle; then there are unpaid rents, and tenants who claim their rent went to the previous owner (even when it didn’t). A lot of headaches, in his words.

But those problems are set to disappear. Because Bricks the proptech is about to mutate. The cause: a bolt from the blue from the AMF at the end of 2022.