18 July. Bricks raises €406,670 at 7% from 2,100 investors in 48 hours.
Some (me included) had their doubts: but the machine isn’t dead!
Bricks has made a lot of noise about its new bond model. Fair enough, since the company went 7 months without raising a penny. On the investment page, explaining what this 7% of income paid out means, Bricks writes, in substance:
That it is an annual rate corresponding to the income paid out […]; that the income is fixed and cannot change over time; and, in bold, that the investor does not bear the risks linked to the property (unpaid rent, vacancies, taxes, etc.).
And there we are, back to Bricks’ old habits.
Because every regulatory document says the opposite, starting with the key investment information sheet that the European rules require:
It warns that investing in this crowdfunding project carries risks, including the risk of losing all or part of the capital invested.
The offering document devotes no fewer than 2 pages to it. It clearly states that the investment’s performance can vary and that there is a risk of payment default and of rent default.
In a livestream in July 2023, Cédric O’Neill hammers the point home:
Whatever happens, he says, the company will pay you these 6% (my note: that was the advertised return at the time) a year, whether the rent is collected or not.
During our conversation, the CEO pleads naivety. True, it’s the project owner who bears the risk of unpaid rent, while the investor bears the risk of the project owner defaulting. Subtle. But he says that following our discussion, the wording has been removed.
The property is bought by the project owner for €310,000. Add the usual acquisition costs, plus Bricks’ commission of €36,970, paid by the project owner. The full amount is being raised, meaning the project owner doesn’t put a single euro into the deal.
Cédric O’Neill tells me he wants to position Bricks as an alternative to the banks.
The idea, he says, is to let bakers finance the premises they trade from.
But if there’s one thing banks know how to do, it’s take security. If they ask for a deposit, it’s because if they lent the acquisition costs too, in the event of an early default, selling the property at its purchase price wouldn’t be enough to pay them back.
As its only security, Bricks accepted a promise to grant a mortgage. It’s legal, but fairly rare. It means the mortgage isn’t registered through a notary. Almost every bank refuses this arrangement because it offers less protection. Basically, it’s “cross my heart”.
For Cédric O’Neill it’s purely a matter of budget: it would have cost 1% of the price on the way in and the same on the way out. A rather thin argument, given that the project owner should have paid for that security. Not the lenders. But the boss is keen to reassure, explaining that he is co-manager of the SPV (with Inès Dias), which probably won’t be the case for future projects.
On the investment’s page on the Bricks website, Inès Dias explains the project owner’s strategy at length. The only point of caution she notes is that it targets students: hence a risk of high tenant turnover.
And yet it seems to me there’s a far more important point of caution:
Basically, if anything goes wrong: it’s squeaky-bum time. 😶
When asked, without being told which platform it was, 2 property crowdfunding players and 1 banker told me plainly that they would never have funded a project with this structure.
With them, it’s 2 years of accounts minimum, the boss of a major platform assures me.
And that was without giving them the numbers. Because if the structure looks fragile… the business plan has full-blown brittle bone disease.
The marketing material estimates €39,000 in annual rent, €27,824 after costs. That’s 6.84% net.
And here the sharpest among you will see it coming: you need a return of around 10% to break even on a purchase with no deposit and a 20-year loan.
But this one runs over 10 years.
The trick lies in the loan: it’s a bullet bond, with the principal repaid in one go at maturity.
No repayment schedule is given, but it’s easy to work out:
That’s a borrowing cost of €284K, against €160K for a standard repayment loan. Which, however, would have meant monthly payments of around €4,720.
So the whole project rests on
The property spitting out €2,318 a month
To pay €2,372 in monthly instalments
In a company with no equity at all.
Enough to doubt that the projects are secure enough for a payment default never to happen, as Cédric O’Neill promised. To gauge that risk, the CEO tells me he takes 3 factors into account:
The LTV (my note: loan to value): will the project owner be able to repay at the end of the project? Here, he says, the flat is priced below market (my note: it will need a 34% capital gain);
The cash flow: if the tenant doesn’t pay, how do you secure things? He says they took into account the cash flows coming into the holding company, around €15K a month;
And a guarantee on the property.
So we can assume Bricks has every confidence in the project owner. All the more so since the holding company set up Ariya Bureaux PDP on 13 June and Ariya Commerces PDP on 5 July. So we may well be seeing it again…
In reality, behind the Ariya holding company is Eymeric O’Neill. Cédric O’Neill’s brother, and a member of the supervisory board of Communauté Bricks 1 SCA (a French partnership limited by shares), a shareholder in Bricks.
It isn’t hidden. In his livestream, Cédric O’Neill says so clearly, explaining that his brother is outside the Bricks company and is neither a shareholder nor an employee. It’s also stated in the documentation.
Someone very close to the European Commission, working on the report on how the regulation is being applied, due out after the summer, analyses this mix:
From a strictly regulatory point of view, this source explains, we are not within article 8.2 (my note: which covers prohibited conflicts of interest) unless the project owner holds more than 20% of the shares. The spirit of the text is another matter: this case wasn’t foreseen, but it is turning up in several structures.
The AMF, which told me it does not comment on individual cases, specifically approved this structure. But it turned down that of another platform, where one of the partners would have left the company to become a project owner.
His brother already had these projects, Cédric O’Neill tells me, so it was a chance to get started. But it’s a drop in the ocean, he says: the aim is to work with people who own offices, shops, complexes. And whatever happens, they are capped at €5M per project owner over 12 months on a rolling basis.
According to Cédric O’Neill, there was no specific procedure to handle this conflict of interest: they followed the same procedure as for any standard investor, he says.
Still, it’s surprising that the first 2 projects funded by Bricks are in Portugal, as were 6 of its last 18 “old model” projects. Which is where Inès Dias, hired for that purpose, is based.
On 2 August, Bricks set up its 3rd SPV for a Portuguese project, which hasn’t been announced yet.