💥 Zero Bullshit
Epilogue

A painful metamorphosis into fintech

In 2 years, Bricks will have created a market that didn’t exist. Unwinding its royalty projects could be a problem. As things stand, some of the properties are reportedly worth less than they were bought for, but Cédric O’Neill is keen to reassure, explaining that Bricks will hold them for a few years while it sells them off (the AMF is letting existing contracts run their course). No doubt at the cost of laborious management and unstable returns.

But Bricks will at least have had the merit of raising questions about how these investments are legally classified, and about the whole model of fractional property. Even if, in the end, what is really fractional is the market itself, split between:

  • Those who fund property development (WeShareBonds, ClubFunding, The Clique, Tokimmo, Fundr etc.), some of which have soaring default rates (I wrote about it here and here);
  • Those who fund the purchase of premises they let on commercial leases (Tantiem, Bloks etc.);
  • Those who do the same for residential property (Atoa, Real-T, Meute Invest etc.)
  • Those who do peer-to-peer lending (where Bricks is heading), but not only for property (Pretup, October etc.);
  • And the sacrosanct AIFs such as OPCIs, SCPIs (French regulated property funds) and other regulated funds.

But that’s only about what gets funded. Because in reality, the ways of funding it are very different:

  • Real-T tokenises shares in LLCs corporations that own the properties;
  • Atoa adapts the idea in France through a fiducie (a French trust-like arrangement);
  • The licensed crowdfunding gang hands out bonds;
  • A few die-hards still stick to the royalties model;
  • While others still have no status at all…

EDIT 15 August: for the past 2 years, RealT has no longer tokenised LLCs but corporations (C-Corps or Inc.), which matters from a regulatory point of view.

All for a modest €1.6bn raised for property in 20221 (vs €10.2bn for SCPIs).

The spirit of the European regulation, which was to simplify and harmonise, is a long way off. Above all, talking to savers and reading a few reviews, it seems obvious that the vast majority don’t understand the difference. Can you blame them?

How do you explain that a buy-to-resell property deal in the middle of rising interest rates is risky? How do you explain to a saver that repayment of their bond depends on a profit of a few euros?

The AMF already raised this point in 2010, highlighting the information asymmetry between non-professional investors and the firms that make or distribute products. Since then, UCITS funds and AIFs (SCPIs included) have been classed as complex. Bonds have not.

That was precisely the role of these licensed platforms: to act as impartial intermediaries and analysts. But many of these projects were born with the “Bricks spirit”, in other words buying properties chosen by the bosses. Not by outsiders.

Did they really have to be pushed into a model they have to bend out of shape? Can you blame them for working around the limits of a system that doesn’t match the spirit of their project?

We’re only at the start of the adventure. Time will weed out the weakest. The market downturn will shake even the best established. And if, unfortunately, savers were to complain, ESMA and the AMF could point out that they had issued warnings and put rules in place.

But nobody is fooled. Those who say they want to protect savers generally protect no one but themselves.

My name is Benjamin Charles, and I advise finance, real estate and web3 companies on branding, positioning and content creation.

👉 Contact me, or reply to this post: benj@mincharl.es

👉 Follow me on LinkedIn

👉 Book a video call to pitch a project or a service (€150 per call)