💥 Zero Bullshit

Bpifrance: state scandal or just another oversight?

An article in Marianne, based on a report by France’s public audit court, talks of unlawful taking of interest and of a whiff of state scandal at Bpifrance.

Last March, the Cour des comptes, France’s public audit court, published a long-awaited report on the performance of Bpifrance, the French public investment bank, which was celebrating its 10th birthday.

It went fairly unnoticed, probably because it is broadly full of praise for the bank. Then it resurfaced on 17 July, after an article in the French news magazine Marianne spoke of a state scandal and of suspected unlawful taking of interest.

But what is really going on?

Illustration for the newsletter “Bpifrance: state scandal or just another oversight?”

Interests: what are we talking about?

You need to understand three quite different notions.

1️⃣ Conflict of interest: when a person (or a company) is in a position where a choice could be influenced by some other consideration.

For example: I work in M&A at an investment bank, and my husband sits on the executive committee of a company involved in the merger. I could take decisions that might, even unconsciously, be guided by my husband’s interests and not only by my client’s.

In finance, there are procedures and a code of ethics to prevent this. Asset managers and investment banks set up what is known as a Chinese wall: departments that might end up working on the same or competing clients are not allowed to pass information to each other. It is almost systematic between the back office and the middle office.

2️⃣ Insider trading: using information that is not known to everyone for your own personal gain.

For example: my sister works in the finance department of a listed company. She tells me about some very good financial results due to be announced in 3 days. I seize the chance to buy 100,000 shares and pocket a profit when I sell them shortly afterwards.

That is exactly what the AMF, France’s financial markets regulator, sanctioned last March: an executive at Schneider Electric who worked on consolidating the group’s results. In 2020, with better-than-expected results about to be published, he bought derivatives giving him exposure to the share price, then sold them at a gain of €342,344.

It is also the story I told yesterday, about Marconi’s stock market flotation in 1912. (in French)

To prevent this, several financial firms forbid employees with access to sensitive information from placing orders on certain products. Some even forbid them from investing actively at all.

3️⃣ Unlawful taking of interest: this French criminal offence mainly concerns elected officials, but more broadly anyone entrusted with a public service mission, under article 432-12 of the French Criminal Code. It usually involves a public decision, taken in the course of one’s duties, that brings a personal advantage.

For example: I am a local councillor, and I get a change to the local zoning plan voted through, which lets my brother build on a plot that could not be built on before. I have used my power to serve an interest that is not the town’s, and therefore not my office’s.

Illustration for the newsletter “Bpifrance: state scandal or just another oversight?”

By the way, what is Bpifrance?

Created in 2012, Bpifrance’s job is to finance companies and help them grow, mainly very small businesses and SMEs, all over France. It is a bank, supervised by the ECB, owned 50% by the French state and 50% by the Caisse des Dépôts et Consignations, the state-owned financial institution.

The company brings together the former activities of the FSI, France’s strategic investment fund, which had roughly the same role, and of CDC Entreprises, which did much the same thing but for the Caisse des Dépôts.

On the other hand, it is not the same entity as the APE, the French state shareholding agency, which is a government department that finances and manages companies and sits on their boards. It was the APE that sold the Française des Jeux, the national lottery operator, and that went back into the capital of EDF, the power utility, in 2022. It notably sits on the boards of La Poste, the postal service (34% stake), SNCF, the state railway (100%), Air France (28%), Orange (23%, alongside... Bpifrance) and Engie, the energy group (20%).

Bpifrance regularly invests in start-ups, for instance, either during funding rounds (in equity) or through loans.

What does the Cour des comptes say?

In a 109-page report that is hardly a page-turner, the Cour des comptes is rather full of praise for Bpi.

First, the Court finds that Bpi’s presence in the private equity market is meant to meet an economic need.

Not only does Bpi finance an economy that needs it, but it has done so with suitable financial instruments which, according to the Court, did not distort the market.

Next, it finds that the investment doctrine has been broadly respected.

The 90 funds and €44bn under management are invested in line with the mission given by the state.

It also notes a significant diversification beyond the original scope.

Through funds designed to invest in multinationals, or by opening funds to retail investors.

It points to a large need for cash.

Although Bpi’s business is described as profitable and its returns are good (x4 in 10 years on average), the report says that this requires a lot of money at all times.

And it judges risk management to be broadly robust.

On the whole, Bpi does not suffer too many losses, thanks to solid procedures and rigorous diversification.

The Court also notes a clear ethical framework, and says that Chinese walls have been put in place to prevent conflicts of interest from arising.

And it is precisely this point that will raise eyebrows a little further down.

Illustration for the newsletter “Bpifrance: state scandal or just another oversight?”