💥 Zero Bullshit
Epilogue

Attractive returns (2/2)

While it is probably true that many sniffed out a good deal, that is because the discount happened in March, whereas the fund opened in October. The markets had already bounced back, and Bpifrance in reality had no other way left to value its fund.

But was it really possible to sniff out a good deal? Not that much, in fact. Because nobody knew about this discount: the documents handed to investors did not let them know exactly what the fund was made of.

Nobody, really?

2️⃣ 200 Bpifrance employees invested in BE1

Among them, Nicolas Dufourcq, the head of Bpi. He explains to Marianne

that he publicly wished staff to subscribe to this product, and that he therefore set the example and wanted them to know he was doing so himself.

And this is where the question gets thornier. Among the 200 employee investors, were there people who knew that, at the time of subscription, there was already an unrealised gain linked to the discount?

Marianne goes on

to say that the financial magistrates, though well versed in muted language, go a long way by raising ethical risks and even the criminal liability of Bpifrance.

And that is a flat-out misreading. On page 47, the report says, in substance, this:

The public bank’s legal analysis concluded that the risk of criminal liability for Bpifrance, and for the employees who had known of the information, was extremely low, if not non-existent.

While it does not rule out a problem, claiming that the magistrates go a long way while deliberately cutting off the end of the sentence is completely dishonest.

So was there potentially insider trading (rather than unlawful taking of interest) by employees who invested knowing about this discount? Nobody answers. But it is hard to imagine that Nicolas Dufourcq was not aware.

In any case, when BE2 opened for subscription, many employees who might have had sensitive information were told directly that they would not be allowed to subscribe.

Probably not enough to call it a state scandal. But enough to raise thorny ethical questions.