💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 04

His Excellency Eugène Rougon

For each loan it places, ClubFunding charges Merlin's group up to 5% of the sums raised.8 The platform advising the bondholders to wait is therefore paid by their debtor. It is also the one that selected the project and rated it 8.2 out of 10. The platform wanted the state to pay for its selection method: in 2022, it asks the tax authorities for a research tax credit, a tax break reserved for research and development spending. The scheme is costly for the state, €6.5bn of claims in 2018, and its usefulness is questioned even within the Finance Ministry: the Treasury finds it has an effect only for small companies, “not for the largest companies”.9 An expert from the Ministry of Research examines ClubFunding's file. His verdict: the method belongs “to the realm of intuition”, with hypotheses that are “often vague”. No tax credit, and on 6 October 2026, the Paris administrative court rules in favour of the tax authorities.10

Judgment of the Paris Administrative Court, 6 October 2026, p. 3

Of the roughly €60M the SGM group borrowed through the platform, ClubFunding may have received up to €3M. The actual amount is not public. Asked by Zero Bullshit, the platform says it received no payment beyond what the bond contract provided for. Once the fundraising is closed, ClubFunding also becomes the bondholders' representative: the platform is in charge of defending the bondholders against the borrower that pays it, and of deciding when to serve formal notice on it and on its guarantors. A very friendly representative.

Because faced with SGM, ClubFunding calls in no collateral. It consults, amendment after amendment, and each rate rise buys a new delay, up to 15% in March 2026.

Elsewhere, when the loan to Michel Ohayon's Financière Immobilière Bordelaise falls due, at the end of February 2023, ClubFunding has precautionary seizures carried out against him, as guarantor of the loan, 5 weeks later.11 On a land deal in Clapiers, near Montpellier, it serves formal notice on the guarantor 3 months after the default and takes him to court less than 1 month later.12 Of the 63 court decisions to which it is a party, 26 make it possible to measure the delay: half of the debtors receive formal notice within 7 months of the incident. For SGM, the capital never becomes due: at each maturity, a vote pushes repayment back. The group, Merlin and Dufour receive the formal notice that triggers the collateral in June 2026, when the coupons are no longer being paid, some 20 months after the original maturity. By then the group owes more than €50M to the platform's clients, spread across 11 loans. Going after Merlin over Roubaix means risking bringing down the borrower of the other 10. An old finance adage sums it up: if you owe your bank €100, you have a problem. If you owe it €100M, the bank has one.

The 63 ClubFunding court decisions

ClubFunding's answer to Zero Bullshit:

“Towards the operator, our line has always been firm. At each payment incident, we demanded that it be made good and served formal notice, the first step in enforcing the collateral.”

Several missed payments were made good this way, according to the platform. The extensions, for their part, were “requested by the operator to complete its refinancing”, then put to a vote, “most often with something in return: a higher rate, staggered repayments”. The answer explains why the capital never became due. It does not say what the platform recommended to the bondholders before each vote.

Every decision that matters to the bondholders goes through a vote that ClubFunding organises, on documents ClubFunding writes, about a borrower that pays ClubFunding, and against which ClubFunding is supposed to represent them.

SGM's bond issues on ClubFunding

Final repayment on 30/10/2026, 100% of par including gross coupons (the rule for SIGM issues, according to ClubFunding)

issuer according to bondholders' posts on MoneyVox (2022 and 2026), to be cross-checked with the ClubFunding page, amount from HC

Final repayment on 30/10/2026, 100% of par including gross coupons (the rule for SIGM issues, according to ClubFunding)

issuer according to bondholders' posts on MoneyVox (2022 and 2026), to be cross-checked with the ClubFunding page, amount from HC

Final repayment on 30/10/2026, 100% of par including gross coupons

issuer named in the 11/08/2026 consultation (MoneyVox forum)

Final repayment on 30/10/2026, 100% of par including gross coupons (the rule for SIGM issues, according to ClubFunding)

issuer according to bondholders' posts on MoneyVox (2022 and 2026), to be cross-checked with the ClubFunding page, amount from HC

Final repayment on 30/10/2026, 100% of par including gross coupons (the rule for SIGM issues, according to ClubFunding)

issuer according to bondholders' posts on MoneyVox (2022 and 2026), to be cross-checked with the ClubFunding page, amount from HC

Final repayment on 30/10/2026, 100% of par including gross coupons

issuer named in the 11/08/2026 consultation (MoneyVox forum)

Final repayment on 30/10/2026, 100% of par including gross coupons (the rule for SIGM issues, according to ClubFunding)

issuer according to bondholders' posts on MoneyVox (2022 and 2026), to be cross-checked with the ClubFunding page, amount from HC

Final repayment on 30/10/2026, 110% of par including net coupons

issuer named in the 11/08/2026 consultation, amount €7.5M or €8M depending on the HC version

€270.29 + ≈€300 of net coupons + €530 on average on 30/10/2026 = ≈€1,100 per €1,000 note

stated by ClubFunding to Zero Bullshit (€3.75M sought, €3.9M according to HC)

Final repayment on 30/10/2026 under the settlement, 100% or 110% of par in total including coupons, depending on the issuer

the ClubFunding memorandum places the asset at the Porte Jeune shopping centre in Mulhouse, amount from HC

Final repayment on 30/10/2026 under the settlement, 100% or 110% of par in total including coupons, depending on the issuer

amount and issuer from HC

Bondholders repaid in full on 04/06/2025 in a merger, according to ClubFunding

stated by ClubFunding

Repaid (HC page 04/2025)

HC status, not verified

Repaid (HC page 02/2025)

HC status, not verified

Repaid around May 2024

link to SGM to be verified (the MoneyVox forum ties it to another operator)

Fundraising cancelled

HC status

Fundraising cancelled

HC status

Fundraising cancelled

HC status