In its letter of 4 December 2014, Aristophil described its sales scheme: joint ownership with a 5-year custody agreement and a unilateral promise to sell in Aristophil’s favour at an indexed price (around 8% a year), with no obligation on Aristophil to buy back. Ownership (outright or joint) was set out in the contract, with Aristophil keeping custody for five years. An in-house ‘study’ boasted of +12.66% a year compounded at auction. Selling was outsourced to networks, notably Finestim and Art Courtage, both since liquidated.
Behind the proceedings, victims are speaking out publicly. Like Thierry Ehrhardt, a business owner from Metz, who had put in 20,000 euros to pay for his daughter’s studies35. He got back only 4,000 euros after suing his broker. He says he has drawn a line under it, and thinks above all of those who lost everything. His story echoes those of thousands of other cheated savers, often kept silent by shame.
Associations have played a central role. ADC France, led by Guy Grandgirard, brings together nearly 800 victims. Grandgirard was one of the first whistleblowers, denouncing as early as 2008 the mechanics of the joint-ownership schemes and the pivotal role of the notary Jérôme Gautry, who drafted many of the agreements (nearly 60).
Surprisingly, most of the few dozen rulings concerned wealth advisers. Actions against banks were often declared inadmissible (only the liquidator could bring them) and/or time-barred.
But out of this mass of rulings, 4 main principles still emerge, which broadly already exist in the regulations, but are worth dwelling on:
This grid turns every Aristophil case into a textbook case. Distributors who had kept their documents, formalised their warnings and limited their clients’ exposure saw their liability reduced. The others now face rulings that can reach several hundred thousand euros, depending on the exposure and their professional indemnity cover.
A pity the rule didn’t come from the professional bodies. It was carved in stone by the courts, one ruling after another.