💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 06

Inland Agency

At the end of November 2022, in a presentation, Lora introduces the late Kirpi.io, which he pitches as high-yield property tokenisation. The famous third pillar, alongside crypto and equity. Quite a programme.

Presentation of the deal. Let’s skip the mix-up between profitability and yield; you can’t ask that much of people who sell property courses.

This is Kirpi’s second deal, the first having been done a few weeks earlier in Agde, on the Mediterranean coast. The difference… is that this one is going to be financed… by Fire Invest.

And on the programme, more dodgy calculations, and more royalties… all to pay out less than the top end of what SCPIs distribute.

But a few details in the forecast surprised me:

  • The fact that Kirpi takes 10.8% in fees on the deal, even though Fire Invest takes management fees, and on top of that at exit;
  • Property management at 10%, at the very high end of the range, when it’s usually more like 4 to 6%. Surprising for property pros not to have a cheaper option. Unless, once again, these are fees for Kirpi;
  • Accounting at €3K a year, which seems very expensive for an SAS, a standard French company, with very few transactions.

And I’ll skip the €30 a month in bank charges: try Qonto17.

All of this gives the distinct impression of a deal with so many fees (18% upfront) that it struggles to be profitable.

Especially since, in reality, Kirpi is going to take other hidden fees. And that is a serious problem.

First on the works. The actual quote for the works, which covers everything down to cleaning the courtyard, is well below €60K. And it’s odd for an SAS to reason in amounts including VAT, when it will recover the VAT on all its costs. So we’re talking about nearly €20K extra that will be billed for no reason.

But another line caught my eye: the estate agency. Because the amount works out at 6.67%. That’s the top end for agencies, but I know very few agencies that choose such a round price.

Especially since, at the same time as Boulanger and Lora create the company Kirpi I, which will hold the two property projects, they create Kirpi18 (plain and simple) under activity code 68.31Z, the one for estate agencies. An activity that requires holding a ‘T’ card, the French licence for property transactions19.

According to Victor Lora, Kirpi’s role was to manage the properties. Except that Kirpi didn’t have a ‘G’ card, for property management, either, according to the CCI20 register.

The most surprising part of the story is that the deed of sale mentions no estate agency for the seller21. Conversely, Kirpi’s accounts, which I was able to see, although, like all the other structures, they were never filed, show this.

Everything suggests that, in reality, Kirpi took €20K in fees on this acquisition, and had already taken €10K on the first, a small building of four studios in Agde bought for €118K.

Asked specifically about this, Lora dodged the question three times.

First on whether there really were agencies on the two sales.

He would have to check whether there was an agency, he says. He isn’t even sure whether there was one or not.
Q. Didn’t Kirpi simply act as an estate agent on those two deals?
A. The aim of Kirpi, he replies, is eventually to offer a platform that lets people propose deals a bit like […] Bricks.
Q. But overall, the deed of sale shows no agency. Why these fees?
A. My view, he says, is biased: it’s like when you negotiate something, it depends on the price you manage to negotiate.

Before half-admitting:

Take a building for sale, he explains, going back to the Biarritz one, at Biarritz or Béziers prices: it’s on the market at €500K. […] If someone tells him they can get it for €300K, provided he hands them 30% or 20% of the discount, 20% of whatever they negotiate paid back to them, then of course, he says, he agrees.

The problem is that this service is the very definition of property intermediation, regulated precisely by the Hoguet law, which governs French estate agents. On top of adding considerable fees.

Because, as a reminder, we’re talking about a €300K property:

  • €24K in purchase costs (which don’t go to Kirpi, obviously);
  • €20K for the fake agency;
  • €40K of Kirpi fees (which makes you wonder what they’re for, then);
  • €15K of margin on the works.

That’s 33% in upfront fees, of which 25% (exactly) for Kirpi.

At that price, of course the deal struggles to be profitable. Especially as this sits inside a Fire Invest deal, so Fire also takes 4% a year, or €12K a year, which probably explains the €15K of cash, by the way.

Add to that the 10% on the rent, taken entirely illegally (at least for a while) by Kirpi, and the €3,000 of accounting a year (per property), which seems out of all proportion for an SAS with two properties…

Especially since an email mentions rents well below what had been announced:

The email gives €5K-€6K per quarter, with €5.8K paid in January 2025 and the next payment in April 2025.

So the talk was of more than €11K a quarter minus €3K of costs, so about €8K. The maths isn’t mathing, Victor.

Apart from Kirpi, it’s hard to see who such a deal could be profitable for…

That said, the purchase is completed in January 2023 and after that… well, nothing.

And yet, on the next slide of the original presentation, when Lora explains his movement at length, he spends a long time on the third of his values: transparency. Always.

They are very transparent, he says, about what they do, the investments, the profitability and so on.

My own personal view: hmm.

In January 2025, plain Kirpi is liquidated after posting €30K of revenue in 2023 and €26K in 2024. Revenue that can only have come from the two deals in question.

While it wasn’t possible to get news of the Agde building, the Montpellier one seems to have been sold. The business plan banked on €500K (for nearly €459K invested), but no offer ever topped €450K, and the property was finally sold for €412K, through a real estate agency this time, a net loss of €48K. Fire will have pocketed:

  • More than €70K in assorted fees via Kirpi;
  • Around €5K-8K for managing the rent via Kirpi ;
  • Around €24K in fund management fees in Fire Invest.

So at least a third of the money invested.

A long way from the goal Lora describes to me, which was to make €1M a month and to have €100M of property, all of it tokenised.

Which inevitably raises the question of how Fire Invest meant to offer 50% a year by investing in a project that banked on 6%.

Just like Fire Invest’s third investment.