💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 02

Blue Fire Velvet

He starts talking about Fire in France around 2019, but it is mostly after Covid, between 2020 and 2021, that he gains visibility, thanks to several media outlets that put him in the spotlight. At the time, it is mostly what we still called meet-ups. And the promise is clear.2

No car, few nights out, free holidays in a family home: within ten years, by his account, this would give him the option of stopping work.

Victor Lora’s storytelling rests on retiring at thirty. Which already poses a first problem. Lora, born in May 1988, turned thirty in May 2018. Yet his own LinkedIn CV shows he was then at Wynd, before joining Bankin’ in 2019. Not exactly the dream retirement.

Then Covid arrives.

Its impact is probably still not fully documented, so hard are the consequences to measure. Not only on the economy. Not only on domestic violence, quickly highlighted either. Nor just the boom in e-commerce or the change in how we see an office and a workspace.

Where we still lack hindsight is the impact of lockdown on financial behaviour. It has been shown several times that people who were, roughly speaking, bored stiff started gambling or buying crypto for a laugh. But it is hard to know the real link with the market explosion that followed soon after, and more broadly with all forms of online investment such as crowdfunding, which we’ve already covered at length here.

Because this is also when the internet sprouted, in abundance, people selling courses to people who will sell courses to people who sell courses. A subject that will get its own newsletter before the end of the year.

Although he is positioned a little differently and promises neither pharaonic returns nor instant riches, Victor Lora indirectly benefits from the craze, precisely among those put off by the cheap sales pitches.

So he turns up at various events and panels, for example at Partech alongside Arnaud Romanet-Perroux of Upstone in February, a little before he starts organising his FIRE drinks in Paris, informal get-togethers for followers (current or future) of the frugalist movement.

But after the first lockdown, he leaves Bankin’ to go full-time on Fire. 3 Which, it must be said, is a tad paradoxical.

He explains that he saved 70 to 80% of what he earned, which takes real effort: even if you’re used to eating out, you hardly go any more, you see your friends less, you move into a flat share, you barely go on holiday. He says he became quite drastic about it.

As for the reality, you know how this goes. As with those for whom image and story matter more than the truth, it is impossible to estimate Lora’s wealth.

On his blog in 20194, he claims to own 10 flats, 60% in the Paris region and 40% in the rest of France, and to run a coworking space in Paris’s 15th arrondissement on autopilot. At the time, when he says he is 31, he makes no secret of still being an employee and says he has reached 40% of his goal.

We also learn that he made his first investment at 21, so in 2009, and that it wasn’t necessarily profitable.

But in an interview, that first investment is instead dated 2011, in Paris, and is said to have been hugely profitable.

He then explains that he bought a building with three flats in Troyes for €45K, until, one thing leading to another, says the article, he owned as many as 200 units. But he supposedly has only about ten left today. Even though he still displays 200 on LinkedIn, which he confirms to me in our interview.

Whereas in 20235 his version was rather this:

He described himself as FIRE since 2020, with business school, engineering school, a US doctorate, 2 years in investment banking, 10 years in start-ups, 100 property units, €1M a year in rent, 12 companies and €20M of investments.

To get there, Lora repeatedly mentions a ‘technique’ in which his father holds the usufruct (the right to use a property and collect its income) of an SCI, a French property-holding company, and his sister is a partner, although the story clearly doesn’t end well. The SCI MILANVIE (Michel the father, Anaïs the sister, and Victor) shows its creation in 2011, and Victor becoming manager in 2018, when his sister left.

This ‘technique’ is actually explained in a Fire newsletter:6

Splitting ownership, the newsletter explains, lets the usufructuary carry the debt.

That is indeed how MILANVIE is set up: Victor and his sister as bare owners, Michel as usufructuary, and therefore, in theory, the one carrying the debt.

Except this is where the story starts to crack. The very principle of split ownership is that the usufructuary collects the rent, while the bare owner waits to recover full ownership. In other words: the income isn’t his.

Yet the whole Fire pitch rests on the opposite: the quest for immediate income, financial freedom, positive cash flow. So we end up with a structure that, for tax purposes, puts the debt on the usufructuary, but economically removes exactly what the Fire doctrine prizes: recurring income.

Especially since, in that newsletter, Lora explains that this is in fact the technique he used to buy his first flat in Paris. Which doesn’t really match the story we know. And which seems to be rewritten as time goes by.

In January 20257, he claims to earn €8K a month, twice as much as ten years ago, without saying whether he means salary, income or turnover. Then again, he says he has €20M in assets.

The reality seems more mundane. In his holding company, Lora owns 2 properties.

  • A one-bedroom flat in Troyes, bought for €55K;
  • One (or two) flats in a residential block in Aubervilliers, just north of Paris, bought for around €250K8;
  • Which brought in €32K in rent in 2022;
  • With no debt.

The SCI MILANVIE also holds 2 properties:

  • A flat in Metz in a nondescript block that looks like social housing, probably worth between €30K and €80K, which he seems to have renovated in October 20217;
  • A flat (or commercial unit) on the ground floor of one of those typical buildings in the 15th arrondissement, where recent sales range from €100K to €350K;

He also holds 70% of an SCI that owns the Marquisat de Guiscard, a very pretty reception venue in the Oise, north of Paris, bought for €704K in 2022.

So, before debt, between €925K and €1,250K of property across five assets. A tidy sum, but a long way from the tens of millions and hundreds of units advertised. While it isn’t impossible that he owns other properties directly, it’s hard to see how that figure could explode. Or why he would hold properties directly when he already has structures for that.

As for companies, he doesn’t own the coworking space we’ll come back to later. That doesn’t stop him talking about it as if he did. As in summer 20219:

Covid-19, he said, had had only negative effects on his companies: for example, he owns a coworking space, but its director left during the crisis and he had to take it over himself.

We’ll see just how much that story matters.

Still, all this storytelling lets Victor Lora move up a league.