💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 03

The Fellowship of the Round

Riding the market’s expansion, Tudigo follows the trend for community funding rounds started by French start-ups such as Qonto, Matera and Masteos. As every marketing type (and CEO) at these start-ups admits, it was a way to raise a bit of money, sure, but above all a way to build loyalty and keep the community engaged while pulling off a nice PR stunt. Because, like every funding round, it will get plenty of media coverage. And customer-shareholders will be much more inclined to come back to the platform rather than another one.

In January 2023, Tudigo raises €3M at a valuation of around €40M.

At the time, the practice raises eyebrows, since the platform is raising money for itself on its own platform, with all the conflicts of interest that implies... explicitly banned by the European crowdfunding regulation... but at that point, Tudigo is not yet a PSFP. The same criticism will be levelled at Blast the following summer, except that Anthony Bourbon’s club was already a PSFP.

Article 8 of the European regulation

Incidentally, in its defamation summons against Zero Bullshit, for which it was ordered to pay the costs, Blast denied having presented its own deal on its own platform, since the regulation does indeed explicitly forbid it.

Extract from Blast’s summons

Well, that’s not true. Blast did offer its own deal on its own platform, as these images show.

For this round, Tudigo creates the SPV Tudigo Partners in the usual format:

  • A French simplified joint-stock company (SAS) with variable capital of €1, which will issue 3M shares for the €3M to be invested;
  • Whose first and sole shareholder is Bulb In Town.

Bulb in Town has had 20 shareholders for 2 years, on top of the 2 founders, who hold 70% of the capital.

A company, Tudigo Holding, is set up to bring together the co-founders’ stakes and the SPV:

  • Each co-founder contributes his shares through his personal holding company, valued at €14.5M, giving each of them 42.5%;
  • Those of Lauriot, co-manager and now a shareholder, who had received free shares, worth €1M, giving 2.5%;
  • The €3M of the SPV Tudigo Partners, giving 7.5%.

As with every community round, the question of valuation comes up.

Because:

  • The higher the company’s valuation;
  • The cooler it looks in the press;
  • And the less the money raised dilutes the existing shareholders.

That’s why these valuations are always the subject of hard bargaining with VC funds:

  • The lower the company’s valuation;
  • The bigger the bite they can take while spending less.

The problem is that retail investors don’t know how to value a company, and have no bargaining power at all: they get sent a deck, and that’s it.

In this case, Tudigo is valued by an independent expert at €40M, for around €4M of revenue in 2022 and €1.1M of EBITDA. In terms of multiples, that’s revenue x10, EBITDA x36. I had already touched on the subject with Blast’s cashout (in French). At the time, the founders valued at €150M a company with €2.2M of EBITDA (x68) and €9.2M of revenue (x16), bearing in mind that the EBITDA and revenue figures actually used were different, for slightly complicated reasons explained here (in French). But overall, in both cases, we’re roughly in the same ballpark.

Compared with Iroko, which was recently valued when its founders carried out an LBO, it looks very expensive. The asset manager was valued at €47M for €15M of revenue and €3.2M of EBITDA in 2023 (and growing fast). But an LBO isn’t really valued the same way, and with a fintech, it’s also a bet on growth.

In any case, this €3M (invested entirely in Tudigo, with no cashout) lets the platform keep funding its growth in a market that is starting to get tricky.