Because 2023 is going to be a pivotal year for crowdfunding, but a hard one for most retail investors to make sense of. Between 2022 and 2023, rising interest rates mainly pushed up the rate on guaranteed savings products, which went from 0.5% to 3%. Even more with some (strangely) structured products. At the same time, crowdfunding posts an average rate
Admittedly, the rise in guaranteed rates and the first delays and defaults slowed fundraising, which came in at just €2bn, against €2.3bn in 2022 (-11.3%), but still well above 2021 (€1.8bn). Above all, retail investors coming through the platforms still account for 63% of the money raised, far ahead of the 20% from independent wealth advisers (up 5 points on 2022), who are in any case concentrated on a handful of players.
Mazars report 2023
But above all, throughout the year, platforms start sweeping delays under the carpet, sometimes not communicating at all. By the end of 2023, delays and losses are exploding.
Tudigo does not publish its figures, like every equity platform, since holding periods are long, and without an exit (or a crash) there is no real valuation. And so no performance to report. All the more so as bonds, particularly in property, are fairly marginal in the business.
Still, Laing feels the wind turning all year long. Especially since, at the end of 2022, Bourbon set himself up against him with the Blast Club, with a big overlap in target audience and a subscription model that will push its members to stop using several platforms, as many do. You’ve got to get your money’s worth out of €1,000 to €5,000 a year! Laing’s idea is to pivot from crowdfunding to club deals, or to an investment fund. A move also under way at Blast, according to its filings with the AMF.
To structure the business, Laing teams up with Guillaume-Olivier Doré (nicknamed GOD in the industry, and I admit that’s pretty cool) at the end of 2023. An entrepreneur who has always worked in finance, GOD co-founded Viadeo, the French professional network, in 2005. Based in Bordeaux, like Tudigo, he spent 4 years at a fund doing impact investing, and advised Patrick Amiel’s start-up studio 321 Founded. Since January 2023, he has run Impact Source, an impact fund financed by Groupe SOS, which brings together a whole raft of charities in France. A monthly consulting contract is signed, to structure things on one side and improve deal flow on the other.
But to set up a fund, a track record is essential. Except that when it comes to putting one together, Tudigo’s teams realise there has been no monitoring. None at all.
A first internal audit is carried out, and its findings are so alarming that a former AMF staffer is appointed RCCI and starts producing numerous notes, deal by deal, on every incident he finds. So much so that an independent audit is commissioned by the RCCI and GOD in early 2025.
Because this is not just a few errors, minor lapses or oversights. The entire structure of the company’s operations has been rotten for years.
The revelations land like an atom bomb, first at the top, then across the whole company as word slowly gets out. All the more so as a war breaks out between Laing and Vromman in their wake.
And in the middle, GOD, the source of the revelations, takes on the role of prophet of doom, delivering the bad news plainly on matters that fell under Vromman’s functional responsibility.
Especially as, over the summer, the discoveries pile up and go beyond belief. So far beyond belief… that they will need a newsletter of their own, and a dedicated read-through by a lawyer to avoid any lawsuit.