An SCI allows fairly flexible management, but above all… it is completely opaque.
None of the 45 SCIs listed by the fund data site Quantalys has filed its accounts in the past 2 years. Unlike their management companies, which are required to because of their licence.
That is no accident: under the EU’s AIFM directive, an SCI is an AIF (alternative investment fund) that does not make a public offering, since investors never subscribe to it directly.
Better still: the co-founder of a management company told me she was not allowed to explain how the SC was managed to savers, because as a product reserved for institutional investors, the AMF, France’s financial markets regulator, did not allow it.
Even though private individuals are the ones who end up benefiting from it.
SCPIs, French unlisted property funds sold to the public, are the opposite case:
In fact, if many of them have seen their value fall recently, it is because they have to revalue their properties regularly, and the AMF made them do it before the summer. Not because they had the courage to do it, whatever Jean-Marc Coly, chairman of ASPIM, the property fund managers’ lobby, claimed last September.
SCPI management companies must also report to partners in great detail on how they manage the fund.
Because in an SCPI, ALL investors are partners: they buy shares in the SCPI’s capital, and the management company is paid to run it. The SCPI does not belong to it.
With an SCI: nothing of the sort. Capimmo’s partners are Primonial and various insurers that sell the fund. They are the ones who get a say in decisions.
Starting to see where this is going?
Note: in a future newsletter, I will come back to the GIANT MESS that SCIs are inside SCPIs, for the same reasons. #teaser