A new company. But really the same old story. Because at heart, SantaREIM sells the veneer of the Coustet/Lenoël duo and their supposed successes, through breezy summaries nobody checks. Or that nobody really wants to check.
Likewise, exactly as throughout this story, exactly as in the Benotmane affair (in French), media and partners relay biographies and turns of phrase without ever checking. Like the dozens of articles, including in trade media, that will describe SantaREIM as a management company, when it does not hold a single AMF licence.
Because in reality, after years running regulated operations, Coustet and Lenoël now operate through club deals.
In the summer of 2024, they are joined by Valéry Fouquet, who spent 25 years in franchised hotels. Then, more surprisingly, by Alexandre Marque, who takes a stake through his Luxembourg holding company. A member of the Paris bar since 1986 and a Swiss tax resident, Marque is above all a very close associate of the telecoms tycoon Patrick Drahi since 2004. Twenty years structuring Altice’s acquisitions, multi-billion LBOs, the complex deals of cable and telecoms. And who therefore turns up in a company with €1,375 of share capital that does deals on 3-star hotels.
The investment thesis fits on three PowerPoint slides. First promise: hotel club deals, buying the buildings and businesses of 3-star hotels. Advertised IRR: above 12%. On 3-star hotels in the provinces. Establishments that are already profitable, to boot. The equation defies the laws of finance the way a perpetual motion machine defies the laws of physics. Second product: “value added” opportunistic property, with returns of between 8 and 10%. All of it dressed up as 150-0 B ter, the tax loophole (letting business sellers defer capital gains tax) that gets French financial advisers excited.
On SantaREIM’s website, a linguistic curiosity: the word risk never appears on its own. It is always escorted by moderate or controlled, or preceded by a saving no. Moderate leverage, no excessive risk, reducing risk without giving up superior performance. The AMF will be delighted.
That said, the deals come quickly.
October 2024, first catch: the Comté de Nice hotel in Beaulieu-sur-Mer. SantaREIM Hotel Invest, the first vehicle, with no number, as if nobody dared start counting yet, gets its hands on 32 rooms between Nice and Monaco. An establishment that was quietly generating its €500K-€700K a year before Covid. Profitable without breaking a sweat.
The local institutions get their chequebooks out. CECAZ19, Bpifrance (France’s public investment bank) and FTCA20 come and stick their names next to phrases about energising the local area.
February 2025, second catch. Hotel Invest 2 treats itself to the Amirauté in Cannes21: 42 rooms opposite the station, a 3-star hotel growing since 2022. Profitable too, naturally. And always the same bullshit words, here from Olivier Besançon of the Fonds Tourisme
The fund’s stated hope: to take part in revitalising the station district in Cannes.
Revitalising a station district, the hardy perennial of French urban planning. As if a refurbished hotel were going to turn a railway station into St Mark’s Square. The same backers follow: CECAZ, Bpifrance, FTCA. When the institutions put money back in, it’s a good sign. Or a sign that they have no political choice but to say yes to a project billed as key for the area.
Meanwhile, the machine speeds up this summer. July 2025, Hotel Invest 3 is created. August 2025, Hotel Invest 4 follows. Two empty SPVs, waiting for prey. The targets remain a mystery. And at this stage those deals have not been able to happen… partly because of this very newsletter.
Because, really, are partners and investors aware that Lenoël’s track record is less smooth than the varnish applied over it? One of them tells me probably not, but that he judges on results. Read: the ones still to come. And after all, why not. People can change. People can improve. You are not always 100% responsible for your failures. You don’t have to focus solely on the negative results.
What is more awkward is that, while Lenoël has undisputed experience of property and club deals, the hotel experience comes from Coustet and his business in Brazil. And the least you can say is that it is very problematic.
So much so that two specialist lawyers, asked specifically about the facts, told me without hesitation that this was enough to fail the AMF’s fit-and-proper requirements.
Which a source inside the regulator, normally tight-lipped and discreet, confirmed to me22.
So much so that an investment services provider, which was about to structure the two club deals for SantaREIM, pulled out at the last minute, when everything was in place, after being questioned.
Which will be the subject of the second episode of this series on SantaREIM.
Asked for comment, neither Olivier Coustet nor Patrick Lenoël wished to respond.