💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 05

3️⃣Prices that won’t budge

I recently wrote several pieces about SCPIs, the French non-listed property funds sold to savers, including one where I was surprised that nobody was talking (at that point) about the ongoing crisis caused by falling portfolio valuations.

  • Transactions are plunging in commercial property: -51% YoY5
  • But so are valuations: -7% for the 284 European non-listed funds tracked by INREV, the European association of investors in non-listed property
  • The AMF, France’s financial markets regulator, listed this decline among its risks for 2023, followed by the Banque de France, the French central bank, which calls it the French financial system’s primary vulnerability.
  • Morgan Stanley talks of -40% on prices6

And yet residential property remains unaffected.

In the United States, the decline has begun: -13% on homes since the start of the year.7

In France it’s still less than 1%: -1.5% in the Paris region, +0.15% in the rest of the country!

Some cities post brazen increases in H1 2023 vs. H1 2022: +21% in Antibes, +14% in Perpignan, +12% in Cannes. More than 20 large cities are up by more than 5%.

It’s an anomaly, because there is a logical correlation between prices, rates and inflation.

  • Property prices follow the broad trend of inflation
  • Property prices follow the broad trend of rates

Which is perfectly normal: it keeps property purchasing power broadly stable.

Every indicator shows that prices should fall. But nothing happens. Why? No study can say for sure.

According to Jacques Friggit, a senior civil servant and property market expert who works on the property price index, the problem lies in a massive rise in prices over 25 years, outstripping incomes.8 Even the crises of 2008 and 2013 only caused slight, temporary dips.

Coming out of the Covid crisis, the huge savings built up were partly used to buy property. Add to that the transactions that had been put off: the market found itself artificially stimulated. And prices with it.

Sellers, who have been told for 25 years that property only ever goes up, and who want to make a killing, are standing their ground. And only urgent sales go through.

So there are fewer sellers, at least not at market price.