💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 06

4️⃣ Honey, I Shrunk the Flat

In property, purchasing power is fairly simple to calculate, with few variables:

  • The number of m²
  • The price per m²
  • The monthly mortgage payment

Floor area isn’t a real variable: on average a studio is 15m², 32m² for a one-room flat, 45m² for two rooms, 65m² for three, 80m² for four, 95m² for five (French listings count every main room, not just bedrooms). A single person is happy with a studio or a one-room flat. Once there are children, the idea is generally to have an extra bedroom for each one.

The price per m², for its part, depends on the market, but also… on the floor area. A studio costs 22% more per m² than a two-room flat, and 39% more than three rooms or more. 9

The monthly payment is rarely a variable. The HCSF, France’s financial stability council, caps the debt-to-income ratio for a loan at 35% (exceptions are possible, but let’s keep it simple). According to the Banque de France, the average debt-to-income ratio is 30%: the margin is thin.

So with prices and the cost of credit both rising, it’s inevitably the floor area that gives.

Back to Patrick & Isabelle.

  • In 2008 their budget let them buy 32m²
  • In 2021: 36m²

In 2023, their €1,500 monthly payment lets them borrow €260,000, or less than 25m²: -30% in floor area!

And they’ll hit the same problem outside Levallois:

  • Grenoble: 138 to 94m² (-32%)
  • Le Mans: 203 to 128m² (-37%)
  • Lille: 108 to 67m² (-37%)
  • Angers: 144 to 79m² (-45%)
  • Bordeaux: 72 to 53m² (-26%)
  • Lyon: 72 to 50m² (-30%)

In most cases, purchasing power shrinks by 1 or even 2 rooms. Enough to put off some buyers? How can anyone imagine taking on 20 years of debt to buy a home that doesn’t fit their life plans?

So properties look overpriced by at least 25%