💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 01

A long, hard report

In the hushed corridors of the Palais Bourbon, home of France’s National Assembly, some fact-finding missions are born of a brutal observation. The one on the returns paid on ordinary people’s savings opens with a paradox that lands like a slap: the French have never saved so much, and their savings have rarely earned so little. At least, that is the conclusion the rapporteurs (the MPs in charge of the report) have been rolling out for the past few days.

But the way they reached that conclusion raises serious questions.

Rapporteurs Without Borders

At the heart of the National Assembly, the Finance Committee is not like other committees. Heir to Parliament’s historic prerogative (consent to taxation), it examines the State budget every year, oversees how budget laws are carried out and keeps watch on how public money is spent.

Traditionally chaired by a member of the opposition, it has around sixty MPs from every political group. Its power? Considerable. It can summon any minister, demand documents from the administration, and carry out checks on paper and on site. It is Parliament’s financial watchdog.

But the committee does more than examine budgets. The National Assembly’s Rules of Procedure2 give it a fairly powerful tool: the fact-finding mission. In practice, the committee appoints one or more rapporteurs to investigate a specific subject.

These rapporteurs then have wide powers: they can hear witnesses, request documents, go out into the field. Their work ends in a public report which, while it has no force of law, can stir consciences and pave the way for future reforms.

That is exactly what happened with the mission on the returns paid on the savings of ordinary people and the middle classes, whose rapporteurs are:

  • Jean-Philippe Tanguy, RN MP since 2022, once close to Nicolas Dupont-Aignan, now a front-rank figure in the RN, close to Marine Le Pen, in whose circle he is nicknamed “Monsieur Économie” (Mr Economy), a pure product of France’s elite schools (Henri-IV, Chaptal, Saint-Cyr, ESSEC, Sciences Po);
  • François Jolivet, a career politician since 1995, first in the centre before arriving in Paris, who has run a parallel career in property (OPAC, ICF/SNCF), who started out in the Gaullist RPR, left it for Emmanuel Macron’s LREM and then joined Horizons. Once said to be close to Bruno Le Maire, the former finance minister, he has sat on the Finance Committee since 2017 and has already written a report on housing, a subject he works on regularly.

The decision to launch this particular mission came at a particular moment. Inflation, which everyone thought had vanished since the 1980s, was making a big comeback. The rate on the Livret A, France’s tax-free regulated savings account, was going up, admittedly, but stayed below price rises. The French were watching their savings melt like snow in the sun.

The Finance Committee decided to get to the bottom of it. It appointed two of its members: one MP from the opposition and one from the majority, a guarantee of objectivity and cross-party spirit.

Tanguy and Jolivet make a politically unlikely but effective double act, which is fairly common in committee, especially when the cameras are not around. For months, they heard every player in the system: the Treasury, the Banque de France, the Court of Audit, the banks, the insurers, the savers’ associations. In all, some thirty hearings that gradually painted the portrait of a system running out of steam.

At least, that is what the conclusion says.

The problem is that the conclusion may well have been whispered by one of the organisations heard, which is also behind Tanguy’s interest in the subject: the FAIDER3, a federation of retirement savers’ associations.

Arsonists in the fire brigade

A parliamentary assistant tells me that it was one sentence from the FAIDER that apparently convinced the committee to launch a fact-finding mission.

According to the FAIDER, between 2021 and 2023, the French lost €300bn of purchasing power on their so-called popular savings: Livret A accounts, euro-denominated life insurance funds, bank accounts.

It is probably no coincidence that this figure appears right in the report’s introduction, which quotes in turn figures from INSEE, France’s statistics office, and the OECD to set the scene. Then comes the famous FAIDER sentence, then another from the AFG4, the asset managers’ lobby, which represents €4,600bn of AUM5. According to the AFG:

A saver who put €1,000 in a Livret A in 2003 ends up with €1,400 in 2023, whereas the same saver, investing in shares tracking the CAC 40 index, would have €2,700!

Exclamation mark.

The figures, especially the FAIDER’s, have been picked up by most of the media covering the story, from Europe 1 to LCP6, the parliamentary TV channel, by way of Capital7 and Le Parisien8.

To tell that story, the AFG sent 3 people:

  • Philippe Sebton, chairman;
  • Dominique de Préneuf, chief executive;
  • Laure Delahousse, deputy chief executive.

Except that Sebton is the former boss of Natixis IM, and since January the top boss of Natixis. And that problem crops up with a good share of the people heard.

Admittedly, the expected institutions are there: the Treasury, the Banque de France, the Court of Audit, the Caisse des Dépôts. But who else did the rapporteurs listen to?

On the side of genuine savers’ advocates, the count is quickly done. France Conso Banque, a consumer association specialising in banking disputes, sent two representatives. The Observatoire de l’épargne européenne, a fairly neutral private think tank made up of former senior civil servants, was represented by one person. That is about it.

Facing them, an armada of lobbyists: three people from the Fédération bancaire française (the banks’ lobby), two from BPCE, two from BNP Paribas, two from La Banque Postale, the French postal bank, three from Crédit Mutuel. On the insurance side, two representatives of France Assureurs, the federation that brings together 260 insurance and reinsurance companies, including Franck Le Vallois, its chief executive, who is also chief executive of MMA, and Philippe Bernardi, former chief executive of Axa Prévoyance. Not forgetting two people from ANACOFI9, two from AGEA (the federation of general insurance agents), and even two from the Institut pour l’éducation financière du public, a financial education body funded in part by... banks and insurers. For property, there is the IEIF10, the property fund managers’ lobby, represented notably by Pierre Schoeffler, adviser to La Française.

All in all, an overwhelming majority of players who make their living selling financial products loaded with fees and commissions.

But luckily, there is also Guillaume Prache, who chairs the famous FAIDER, which claims to represent 1.4M members.

Except that… behind the rather generic label of consumer association, blah blah blah, lies a slightly more complicated reality…

Insurers Anonymous

Founded in 2005, the FAIDER exists to aid (sorry) a whole constellation of associations.

Some are widely recognised, such as ADAM11, chaired by Colette Neuville: for decades, this champion of small shareholders has been battling at the general meetings of big companies to defend minority shareholders. Her work is recognised and respected by all.

But others raise rather more questions.

Take ANCRE, for instance. Its chairman, Patrick Grosjean, is none other than the former head of operations at Allianz France, and a member of its executive committee until 2018. On the website of this association, which is supposed to defend savers, you will find... 11 Allianz products. Nothing else. Its head office is at 27 boulevard des Italiens, in a fine building bought by Allianz Invest Pierre. A consumer association, or a marketing arm of the insurer? The line gets blurry.

AGIPI12 plays on a similar ambiguity. Founded in 1976, this self-styled policyholders’ association claims 620,000 members and manages €20bn of savings. Impressive. Except that AGIPI is first and foremost a partner of Axa and mainly sells... Axa products. Its chairman, François Pierson, is in fact the former boss… of Axa. A defence association, or a distribution network in disguise?

Same pattern with the Association Liberté Retraite de La Banque Postale. Its chair, Danielle Wajsbrot, is none other than the former head of La Banque Postale’s insurance division, a post she held for twelve years. But where it gets really interesting is that ALR is not just a consumer association: it has GERP13 status, registered with the ACPR, France’s banking and insurance supervisor. In plain terms, it is a structure that takes out and manages retirement insurance contracts. Its registered office is at 4 promenade Cœur de ville in Issy-les-Moulineaux. The same address as CNP Assurances, La Banque Postale’s insurer.

And what about PERF, the association for the Promotion de l’Épargne et la Retraite des Français [Promotion of French People’s Savings and Retirement]? Its chairman, Alexis De Rozières, also runs Eres, which proudly presents itself as bringing together the best of employee savings and personal savings, for you. The association offers two products, both PERs, France’s retirement savings plans: PER Eres with SwissLife and PER Eres by Spirica. No relation whatsoever, obviously. As for the head office, no prizes for guessing: it is at 115 rue Réaumur in Paris’s 2nd arrondissement. Exactly the same address as Eres Assurances, the group’s brokerage firm.

Or else there is:

  • GAIPARE, €3.6bn of AUM, which sells 2 products, Allianz only.
  • ASAC-FAPAS and its €4.5bn, whose chief executive came from Alataprofits (Generali) and Prédon (CNP), and which sells… CNP, Allianz, Spirica and Generali.
  • Avenir Retraite, which sells the products of Monceau Assurances, a mutual group managing €11bn
  • AMPLI, and its AMPLI-CRISTAL contract, insured by... CNP. When CNP decided to transfer its retirement portfolio to a new structure, the association simply told its members that it would make sure their rights were properly preserved and that it had no reservations to express. Good boy.
  • And a few others of the same kind.

In the end, the FAIDER looks less like a federation of savers’ associations than a club where insurers have placed their representatives. Of its 13 member associations, how many genuinely defend savers’ interests rather than those of insurance companies? The question is worth asking when you see that most are run by former insurance executives, sit in their premises, or are just brokers dressed up as associations, a far cry from the cupcakes sold at the school bake sale to pay for the class trip to the theme park.

That is the context in which to read the €300bn supposedly lost, as brandished by the FAIDER. The question should be: lost for whom?