💥 Zero Bullshit
Epilogue

Lobby, mon amour

Admittedly, it would be in bad faith to claim this report is rubbish and that there is nothing worth keeping. But one may be surprised at the poor quality of what is written in it and the platitudes it contains. It is a far cry from the technical rigour and precision of the Mattei / Sansu reports on taxation29, those by de Courson on property or taxation, or the detailed analyses of the Court of Audit or the Conseil des prélèvements obligatoires, a public body that studies taxation. Or even the one on the State’s property policy, co-signed by the same MP Jolivet30. And yet that is exactly what you expect from this kind of publication, paid for with public money.

But to miss the subject of regulated savings so completely, on the one hand, and to promote the interests of certain players so heavily, on the other, is strange.

Because the rapporteurs very clearly lean towards positions that suit savings managers. On the subject of sight deposits, Tanguy writes plainly, in the third person:

That Banque de France data lead the rapporteur Jean-Philippe Tanguy to consider that a large part of these savings should be placed in other products.

He then explains that households think this money is protected while sleeping at the bank, when it is taking the full force of monetary erosion, which is the classic, everyday argument of every product seller and so-called financial educator.

Is it wrong? Not entirely. But it is surprising that the rapporteur first explains that guaranteed savings should protect against inflation… before saying that, in the end, they should be placed elsewhere.

All the more so as the report justifies it with what everyone already knew: the rich put more into risky products. What the report completely sidesteps is that the wealthiest also have access to better products.

By promoting rubbish PE and other bank SCPIs (French non-traded property funds) that barely beat inflation, the report rather forgets that the middle classes it talks about do not have access to the best-performing products. It forgets that when we talk about the average figures of an asset class, those of retail investors are always a long way off, because the amounts they invest do not give them access to the best investments, and they end up en masse with underperforming, fee-laden products. On top of a panicked fear of risk, due to not knowing what a good allocation should be, depending on one’s investment horizon, and therefore one’s goals.

Because ultimately, that is perhaps what the report should have tackled. And in a way, Tanguy and Jolivet are doing exactly what they claim to denounce. They talk about the solution, the Livret A (and its little friends), without ever asking themselves about the original problem.

The role of the Livret A was never to provide an investment that is both profitable and guaranteed. And the reverse goes for risky products. The aim of guaranteed savings, and it is almost unique in the world, is to pay interest on small cash savings, in exchange for a rate that covers inflation more or less-ish, while financing projects of common interest.

How it is implemented is debatable. But you still need to know what you are debating.

As for the question of who defends French savers, the answer is not in the parliamentary report. Nor is the answer MP Tanguy. Nor is it the litany of managers, insurers and other intermediaries heard for the report.

The law says it should be the AMF, the ACPR, the CNIL (the data protection watchdog) and the DGCCRF (the consumer protection and fraud watchdog), which themselves answer to their little European friends. But the collapse of crowdfunding, to name just one case regularly covered here, shows just how little the regulation was designed with savers in mind.

But have Tanguy and Jolivet ever read a KIID (the key investor information document) or a prospectus, which are supposed to protect savers?

What we do know, on the other hand, is that the State, through the Institut national de la consommation, its consumer body, is going to sell its magazine 60 Millions de Consommateurs, which risks becoming an advertising dump like every title bought by Czech billionaire Křetínský in recent years.

What we also know is that the State, through the Caisse des dépôts et consignations, is going to wind down the activities of Novethic, a sustainable finance media outlet, unless a buyer turns up.31

What we still don’t know after reading this report is who is really going to protect savers.

Contacted by email, Jean-Philippe Tanguy did not respond.

At Zero Bullshit, we often talk about the industry’s problems. But we also need to offer solutions. That is why we now work with a partner specialising in supporting and financing complex financial, wealth or family disputes.

This firm brings together a pool of experts, backed by a solid group with more than €100M in capital.

In practice: if you are facing a long and costly financial dispute, we can look into the case. And the work will only be paid for if it succeeds.