💥 Zero Bullshit
Chapitre 01

Back to reality

While I was working on this issue, Cleerly, the French investment website, published exactly what I was putting together: an overall view of what really happens to the deals. So (ONCE YOU’VE READ THIS NEWSLETTER) you can go and have a look at this:

Overall, across the first 5 seasons:

  • €26.1M was promised on set by the investors;
  • €10.9M was actually invested through 61 deals out of 122, so one in two.

The press had a field day with that ratio a few months ago. Among the stories was that of an entrepreneur whose deal with Tony Parker, the former NBA star, fell through1, and who went on to post one LinkedIn whinge after another2. This famous “Camille”, whose first name had supposedly been changed according to France Info, the public news broadcaster, is perfectly well known. Her name is Camille-Cécile Lambert, and she was telling her story publicly, under her real name, at the very same time. Her company, ADN Group? A simplified limited company (SAS) set up in 2022, €1,000 of share capital, zero employees, declared activity: wholesale trade.

Because the problem is that a lot of entrepreneurs, especially on this show (but not only), want to raise money to save their company. Others just use it to get people talking about them. Or even to launch a crowdfunding campaign aimed at retail investors3, which often ends badly, like Horiz.io, liquidated a few days ago after tapping its community for 200K on Crowdcube (naturally). Clearly, in Camille’s case, it was a bit of both: saving her company and getting media attention. All this after trying to raise €1M (the potential €200K from the show couldn’t have funded the company anyway), then looking for a right-hand person, on condition that they made an initial investment. Less than 3 months ago, the same CEO was trying to launch a crowdfunding round starting at €500, but seems to have given up after 58 responses, 12 of them a probably not.

Maybe Parker simply had a good nose.

Four members of the panel, past or present, point to the same reasons. Jean-Pierre Nadir (seasons 2 to 4, then occasional guest in seasons 5 and 6) sums them up for me in three categories.

1: candidates who don’t want the deal, or no longer want it, he says. Either because they only wanted the spotlight […] or because they want to change the terms.
2: those who oversold their future. […] When they go on the show, they give information that never materialises, such as funding or a distributor.
3: those who announced figures that bear no relation to the truth. For example, margins that aren’t there, higher production costs, working capital needs that are about to explode.

It’s neither scandalous nor a scam, whatever the mainstream press may have said. It’s perfectly normal. A TV slot lasts a quarter of an hour, for roughly 1h to 1h15 of filming. That’s not enough time to check a business plan or the truth of what is being said.

As for results, still according to the Cleerly table:

  • 1 exit (La French Baguette)4;
  • 46 insolvency proceedings (including Bob (in French) and Nanaba (in French)), or 20%5.

According to one former investor on the panel, these figures, which are in fact fairly close to (or even better than) the reality of the French start-up scene as a whole, are mainly down to the quality of the pitches. Especially since, he adds, the worst pitches are never broadcast. Another panellist says bluntly that if the funds he invests in offered a deal flow that rubbish, he would have pulled out long ago.

Because a good QVEMA start-up isn’t a profitable start-up, or one with a good product. It’s a company with a good story to tell, a product that’s easy to understand, ideally one you can show on screen, and that speaks to viewers. Because QVEMA isn’t Kima or Antler, the early-stage investors: it is first and foremost a TV game show that needs ratings to make money.

So why do the panellists hand over around half a million a year for a return that’s not great? Well… it depends. But nothing is ever really free.

Not least because the panellists don’t all have the same background or the same legitimacy. And to understand who sits around the table, you first need to understand how M6 recruits them.